Foreign nationals are massively over-represented in Italian crime data released this week—and the figures are expected to be even worse for illegal migrants.
The information from the Interior Ministry shows that the incidence of foreign arrests is higher than that of Italians when it comes to
robberies (52.3%), including public robberies (60.1%), snatching (61%) and theft by sleight of hand (69%).
The percentages are lower for
sexual assault (43%),
drug dealing (39%),
car theft (24.5%),
smuggling (29%) and
intentional homicide (23.7%).
But foreigners are overrepresented in all these cases, too, considering they make up just nine percent of the Italian population.
The figure on sexual violence is particularly interesting, given Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni’s claim almost exactly a year ago that rising immigration is responsible for increased violence against women.
Italian crime researcher Paolo Pinotti told the Il Sole 24 Ore newspaper that “the data provided by the Interior Ministry does not reveal a breakdown between legal and illegal immigrants reported or arrested during the year.” He suggested that if it did, illegal migrants would bear the brunt of the responsibility for this overrepresentation.
Foreigners who are legally present in the country, on the other hand, have a propensity for crime in line with that of Italians.
Migrants account for the highest portion of arrests in the Tuscan city of Prato (62%). Milan and Florence are not that far behind, at 55.8% and 56% respectively.
Similar reports on migrant crime crises have emerged in recent years in France, Germany, and elsewhere across the continent.
The German Government has reportedly started to offer money to Afghan citizens in Pakistan slated for resettlement in Germany to get them to not come into the country.
As newspaper Weltreported yesterday, the German interior ministry has started sending letters to Afghans in Pakistan previously admitted to a resettlement programme. In one case, it offered recipients a €10,000 “starter bonus” for them to return to their home county instead of being flown to Germany.
In addition, they are offered a €2,500 one-off payment to facilitate their emigration from Pakistan.
In another example, a family of four was offered a €2,750 instant payment and €11,500 upon their arrival in Afghanistan.
According to State newscaster Tagesschau yesterday, there are currently 2,100 Afghans in Pakistan awaiting transport to Germany.
The interior ministry confirmed the situation, saying: “There are offers within the framework of a voluntary return programme to Afghanistan or departure to another third country.
“The aim is to give prospects to people who cannot expect to be accepted in Germany.”
The Afghans in question had previously been granted the right to move to Germany. Most of them are currently living in Pakistan, having fled their home country after the takeover by the radical Islamist Taliban in 2021.
Germany has tried to walk back on its promises, with new interior minister Alexander Dobrindt (Christian Social Union, CSU) announcing a temporary pause in May 2025.
The German embassy in Islamabad, Pakistan’s capital, refrained from giving out visas to the Afghans in question or cancelled existing visas.
German courts, though, have repeatedly ruled in favour of the Afghans, ordering authorities to fly them out from Pakistan to Germany.
Since the new government of Friedrich Merz (Christian Democratic Union, CDU) took over in May there have been four flights in which 110 Afghans were transported to Germany.
In the latest case, a flight carrying 31 Afghan citizens from the programme landed in Hanover yesterday.
The interior ministry is now trying to pay its way out of the legal obligations created by the previous left-wing government.
According to Welt, the letters to Afghans were sent out in earlier this month, asking recipients to decide by the middle of the month whether they wanted to take the money.
If the Afghans accept the offer, they have to declare they are leaving the programme. A restart of procedures at a later stage has been ruled out.
The GovernorHub quiz was removed from its website following backlash from parents and MPs | GOVERNORHUB
School governors across England have been told to dismiss fears about grooming gangs as “disinformation”, it can be revealed.
Thousands of volunteers for education governing bodies were presented with various scenarios during safeguarding training, including one involving rumours of “men belonging to a particular religion” committing “violent crimes against women”.
They were reportedly asked to identify the scenario as an “online safety risk” because pupils were spreading “disinformation”, according to The Daily Telegraph
The course — which MPs and parents branded as “shocking” and “concerning” — was delivered by GovernorHub, a third-party platform that is used in two-thirds of schools across the country.
The shocking revelation comes as hundreds of previously closed investigations into group-based child sexual abuse and exploitation (CSAE) are being reviewed by the National Crime Agency.
The GovernorHub material was disclosed by a concerned parent and part-time governor, who was outraged at the idea of schools being forced to reject evidence of grooming gangs.
“For governors to be trained to behave in a way that would enable further such abuse is sickening and highlights the casual attitude so many still have towards these evil crimes,” they said.
The GovernorHub scenario, which has since been deleted, stated: “At a board meeting, your staff governor reports overhearing pupils in her class talking about a video they were sent, falsely claiming that men belonging to a particular religion are using new tactics to commit violent crimes against women in your local area.”
In 2022, the Independent Inquiry into Child Sexual Abuse (IICSA) recommended mandatory safeguarding courses for all governors following concerns that evidence of minors being abused was routinely ignored for decades by schools, councils and the police.
Chris Philp, the Conservative MP and shadow home secretary, said: “It is shocking that training for schools categorises what sounds like a description of a rape gang as ‘disinformation’ or a ‘conspiracy theory’.
“We now know that the majority of rape gang perpetrators were of Pakistani origin. Claiming this is ‘disinformation’ is exactly how the rape gang scandal was covered up in the first place.
“This so-called training is a disgrace, and little more than propaganda designed to aid the cover-up of these appalling crimes.”
A GovernorHub spokesman said: “The question was intended to test governors’ understanding of the difference between misinformation, disinformation and conspiracy theories, which the most recent update to Keeping Children Safe in Education (KCSIE) requires.
“It focuses on what a governor might do if they become aware of online content that school leaders know to be untrue.
“This question forms part of GovernorHub’s safeguarding refresher training introduced in September this year.
“We have recognised that the scenario included in this question was inappropriate because it made the question unclear and we are revising it this week.”
Under Operation Beaconport, the NCA is reviewing cases where police forces and the Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) took no further action against suspects between January 1, 2010, and March 31, 2025.
Sarah Champion, the MP for Rotherham, told GB News: “Let us never forget that at the heart of every case the police or CPS decided not to pursue, there is a child horribly exploited and abused — and a perpetrator who got away with it.
“I would suggest the numbers are just the tip of a very dark iceberg; understandably, very few victims report or are taken seriously when they try to.”
The British government placed a convicted paedophile wanted by German authorities in a migrant hotel and is paying for his legal defence against extradition, sparking outrage from local MPs.
Izalden Alshaik Suleman, 32, was detained by the National Crime Agency (NCA) at the Britannia Ashley Hotel in Hale last month and now faces deportation to Germany where he is wanted for a child sex offence.
His detention at the hotel, which has been used to house alleged asylum seekers at taxpayer expense since 2023, has sparked questions as to why the government placed the convicted paedophile within the accommodation in the first place, rather than immediately removing him from the country.
Speaking to the Altrincham Today publication, Local MP Connor Rand said: “The individual who has been arrested should never have been allowed into the country. I understand they now face extradition, and I will be writing to the Home Office to request they are deported as soon as possible.”
Rand went on to reveal that the NCA failed to inform local authorities, including himself, the Greater Manchester Police, or the local Trafford Council about their plans to arrest Suleman as the hotel.
“While I am grateful to the NCA for their work to apprehend a clearly dangerous individual, I share the anger of residents that we were kept in the dark about such a serious incident,” he said.
A member of the governing left-wing Labour Party, Rand said that he has urged Prime Minister Starmer’s government to shut down migrant accommodation at the Ashley Hotel as well as the Cresta Court migrant hotel, and said that he has received assurances that they will both be shut, but did not disclose any timeline.
The leader of the Trafford Conservatives Cllr Nathan Evans said that it was “outrageous” for a convicted pedophile to be housed in the hotel, saying: “We have been mocked by the Greens, Lib Dems, Labour and I even got a letter from the churches saying we were wrong to call these facilities inappropriate. These are the places we should not be housing these illegal migrants.”
When the Ashley Hotel was commandeered by the previous Tory government in 2023 to house migrants, then-MP Sir Graham Brady said that it was the “most obviously inappropriate location you could imagine” to house supposed asylum seekers.
The following year, the government also took over the Cresta Court hotel in Altrincham to house asylum seekers. According to the local report, around 300 migrants still reside in the hotel at taxpayer expense.
The disclosure that the government was housing a convicted paedophile in a migrant hotel comes in the wake of months of protests against the scheme to house mostly young male illegals in hotels across the country and concern for the safety local women and girls.
The protest movement was sparked in July after Ethiopian illegal Hadush Kebatu sexually molested a 14-year-old girl outside of the Bell Hotel in Epping, where the government placed him after he broke into Britain by boat over the English Channel.
Adding insult to injury, last month, Kebatu was “mistakenly” released from prison early, kicking off a nationwide manhunt and terror for his victim.
Kebatu was ultimately caught — after authorities initially turned him away as he sought to turn himself in — and was given £500 in taxpayer cash to voluntarily leave the country. While Suleman has not been offered direct cash, the state is still paying for his legal defence against extradition proceedings to send him back to Germany to face justice for his child sex crimes.
The Home Office said: “Mandatory security checks are an essential part of our border controls and are conducted on all small boat arrivals. Where criminals or threats are identified, we seek to remove them as soon as possible.”
On a horrific Wednesday morning on Île d’Oléron: at around 9.30 a.m., a motorist deliberately drove into pedestrians and cyclists between Dolus-d’Oléron and Saint-Pierre-d’Oléron, injuring ten people, two of them seriously. The driver, a Frenchman unknown to the secret services, was arrested shortly after the incident when he attempted to set his vehicle on fire.
According to Le Parisien, witnesses said he shouted ‘Allah Akbar’ from behind the wheel before driving into the victims. Investigators are not ruling out a psychiatric motive, but are examining every element of a terrorist nature. The scenes followed one after the other: a pedestrian was run over near the Intermarché de Dolus, then two cyclists were run over in Saint-Pierre-d’Oléron, on Rue de la Cure and Rue des Godillons, before another collision occurred on Route d’Arceau.
The man was arrested without resistance and taken into custody. Residents on the island are in shock and fear that a ‘simple walk’ could now turn into a tragedy. One of them confides: ‘We no longer feel safe anywhere.’ Many lament a feeling of abandonment as the peaceful island of Charente-Maritime is suddenly confronted with a terrifying incident.
Women are outraged after Glamour UK named a group of gender-confused men as ‘Women of the Year.’
On October 29, the women’s lifestyle and fashion magazine British Glamourcelebrated nine gender-confused men as their 2025 Women of the Year, sparking backlash across social media as the magazine was accused of canceling real women in favor of gender-confused men.
“As trans rights face increasing threat in the UK, Glamour honours nine of the community’s most ground-breaking voices at this year’s Women of the Year Awards,” the magazine wrote in a post on X. “From fashion and music to charity and activism work, these trailblazers work tirelessly to empower, uplift and celebrate trans voices.”
Comments under the post roundly condemn the magazine for their selection of nine gender-confused men.
“Glamour is a magazine for young girls,” one user commented. “It was toxic enough when I was a teenager, pushing unrealistic beauty expectations.”
“I can’t imagine what young girls must be thinking now, you hold men up as “Women of the Year” erasing women and girls, an absolute disgrace,” the user continued.
Similarly, many prominent female figures quickly called out the magazine for essentially telling women that gender-confused men who have undergone surgery and a fashion makeover can be better women than women themselves.
“I grew up in an era when mainstream women’s magazines told girls they needed to be thinner and prettier,” Harry Potter author turned women’s activist JK Rowling wrote on X.
“Now mainstream women’s magazines tell girls that men are better women than they are,” she continued.
British rapper, author, podcaster, and public speaker Zuby likewise condemned the selection, writing, “The ‘trans movement’ is easily the most misogynistic movement in modern history. Especially because of it’s scale and mainstream acceptance.”
Additionally, Oil London, a British detransitioner, commented,” Glamour magazine UK features 9 Transgender men on the cover and calls them ‘Women of the Year.’ ”
“The magazine has called 9 trans activists ‘trailblazers’ and has awarded them with the Women of the Year award for their ‘resilience and sisterhood,’” he continued.
If it wasn’t enough for transgender athletes to steal women’s sports awards, the men are now not only claiming ‘Women of the Year’ awards but also descending women’s beauty pageants.
As LifeSiteNews previously reported, in 2023, a man named Miss Portugal advanced to compete with another man for the title of Miss Universe, a female beauty pageant now owned by a “transgender” businessman.
Similarly, in 2024, a men was crowned the winner of Miss Maryland USA, a contest that promises a “fair environment in which young women have the opportunity to develop skills that will help them win in life by being their personal best in everything they do.”
The Bureau of Prisons has been ordered to provide laser hair removal and other cosmetic services to a transgender pedophile currently incarcerated for sexually abusing his own 10-year-old son. Brian Buckingham, 47, changed his name to “Nani Love” and declared that he identified as “female” just before he was sentenced for the horrific crime.
Reduxx can exclusively report details from the disturbing case, the investigation into which began in February of 2020 after popular chat service Discord became aware of child sexual abuse material being uploaded to its platform.
Discord had received a report from a concerned user about abuse images that had been made public, and a human moderator verified the contents of the report and immediately notified the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children (NCMEC). Based on the IP address of the account associated with the image, the NCMEC went on to involve the Washington State Patrol. A detective was assigned to the case to review the evidence from Discord, which included an image file depicting an adult man preparing to penetrate the anus of a young child.
In April of 2020, a court issued a search warrant to Discord for all of the information associated with the account the image had originated from. Reviewing selfies the account had uploaded to various group chats, the Washington State Patrol was then able to confirm the owner of the account was Brian Buckingham of Neah Bay. An additional package of media provided to police by Discord revealed two videos featuring Buckingham and a child victim that was later determined to be Buckingham’s own 10-year-old son.
The videos, which were taken on what police described as a covert security camera that had been positioned somewhere in the room, were shared with another Discord user who actively encouraged Buckingham to sexually abuse his child.
Conversations between Buckingham and the other Discord user reveal that Buckingham frequently exposed his young son to homosexual and bisexual pornography.
An exchange between Buckingham, using the alias “The_Awkward _Package” and a Discord pedophile.
Continuing the investigation, the Washington State Patrol found that Buckingham had exchanged Discord messages expressing an interest in rape and sexually abusing animals and toddlers. Buckingham also shared child sexual abuse material with other Discord users, and even engaged in sexually exploitative chats with at least one user who identified themselves as being 13.
Buckingham utilized multiple social media platforms, including Discord, to advertise his aspirations to become a gaming streamer focused on Rocket League. He went by several handles, including “The_Awakward_Package,” “DoubleDoc,” and “GamingDaddy” on TikTok, YouTube, and Periscope.
On a YouTube channel confirmed by Reduxx as belonging to Buckingham, the predator promoted his own full line of self-branded merchandise despite only having 73 subscribers.
Buckingham was also active in Native American suicide prevention campaigns as a neurobiology student at Washington State University. An X account belonging to Buckingham reveals that he was on the Washington State Suicide Prevention Plan Steering Committee in 2015, and met with Senator Tina Orwall in 2015. In 2017, Buckingham was listed as a Substance Use Program Manager at Circles of Care, a community health service for the Makah Indian Nation.
On June 2, 2020, the Washington State Patrol obtained a search warrant for Buckingham’s residence. Upon questioning, Buckingham denied any sexual contact with minors, and initially denied ever exchanging any sexual abuse media on Discord.
Brian Buckingham advertising his self-branded merchandise in a screenshot from his YouTube account.
Because Buckingham is a member of the Makah Indian Nation and the crimes were committed on Makah land, the case was referred to the Federal Bureau of Investigation. In the United States, major crimes committed in Indian Country are unable to be prosecuted by state officials and fall under the jurisdiction of the federal government.
Buckingham was initially indicted on two counts – one of the production of child pornography, and one of the distribution of child pornography. But the indictment was later revised to include three counts of the production of child pornography, one count of the distribution of child pornography, and one count of aggravated sexual assault on a child.
Buckingham’s case was slow-moving through the justice system due to the COVID-19 pandemic. His attorneys also pressed for a comprehensive mental health evaluation to determine his competency to stand trial. His attorneys briefly began to explore the possibility of a “sexsomnia” defense after receiving a report that suggested Buckingham may have a tendency to perform sexual acts in his sleep.
On December 4, 2024, Buckingham waived his right to a trial and entered into a plea agreement, admitting to the production of child pornography and abusive sexual contact with a child.
Brian Buckingham. Photo Source: FACEBOOK
Just prior to being sentenced, Buckingham’s attorneys submitted a memorandum informing the court that he now identified as transgender and had changed his legal name to “Nani Love Buckingham.”
In a court document dated March 20, 2025, the pronouns used to refer to Buckingham were swapped to “she/her” and his transgender identity abruptly became the focus where it had not been mentioned at all in dozens of previous filings.
The memorandum claimed that Buckingham was suffering from “gender dysphoria” and had become depressed in wake of the Executive Orders issued by the Trump administration prohibiting the Bureau of Prisons (BOP) from “affirming” the “identity” of federal inmates who identify as transgender. It also revealed that the Bureau of Prisons had previously hastily arranged “gender-affirming medical treatment” for Buckingham just prior to Trump’s inauguration, but that the procedures had been abruptly cancelled due to the Executive Orders.
“BOP previously provided Buckingham with gender-affirming medical treatment and accommodations to address her gender dysphoria, including hormone therapy. The gender-affirming health care she was receiving afforded her relief from the distress of gender dysphoria and significantly improved her mental health,” the document reads. “However, the hormone therapy has now ended and the gender affirming surgery that was previously scheduled has now been cancelled. As a result, Buckingham’s depression and suicidal ideation have been exacerbated.”
Buckingham’s defense requested he be allowed to serve his time in FCI Butner in North Carolina, writing that the “reputation of this facility is that it is a safer location for transgender individuals, there is better access to psychiatrists, there are stronger health services available.”
The court ultimately imposed a sentence of 252 months in prison, and adopted the recommendation that Buckingham serve his sentence at FCI Butner. He was also ordered to pay $2,450 in restitution.
Just prior to the sentence being formalized in that case, Buckingham had already begun to file a lawsuit against the Federal Bureau of Prisons and Trump administration officials for alleged violations of his human rights.
In a motion filed in April of 2025, Buckingham claimed that Bureau of Prisons had violated his Eighth Amendment rights and his rights under Section 2 of the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990 by denying him access to “medically necessary care.” Buckingham described himself as a “transgender female” in the motion, and claimed that he was at risk of irreparable harm if the accommodations were not provided to him.
From Buckingham’s lawsuit agains the federal government.
“My mental health, psychological well being, and my ability to function have been severely damaged. I am in constant pain. I feel like I am being tortured, and I am very close to killing myself to make it stop,” Buckingham wrote. “I want an emergency temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction requiring the [Bureau of Prisons] to resume my life-saving, medically necessary [gender dysphoria] treatment and accommodations before I kill myself.”
Buckingham submitted two declarations to support his case, including one from Dr. Dan H. Karasic, a Professor Emeritus of Psychiatry at the University of California San Francisco. Karasic recommended Buckingham be scheduled for immediate consultations for “facial feminization surgery, laser hair removal, and voice/speech therapy as gender affirming care.”
On September 18, United States Magistrate Judge David Christel filed a report determining that Buckingham was “likely to succeed” on the merits of his claims that his Eighth Amendment rights against cruel and unusual punishment had been violated.
“Buckingham has presented evidence that she suffers from a serious medical need, gender dysphoria. She also has presented evidence that Defendants were aware of her need for the Consultations,” Judge Christel wrote, referring to Buckingham with feminine pronouns. “The evidence shows BOP healthcare providers at FDC SeaTac referred Buckingham for the Consultations, and then BOP healthcare providers at FCI Butner discontinued the requests for the Consultations without reason and summarily denied her request for the facial feminization consultation … The undisputed evidence shows the Consultations are medically necessary.”
Judge Christel then recommended Buckingham’s motion for a preliminary injunction be granted, and that an injunction ordering the Bureau of Prisons to provide him with the cosmetic consultations be issued. Explicitly included were those for laser hair removal, facial feminization surgery, and voice training.
United States District Court Judge Ricardo Martinez adopted Christel’s recommendations, and gave the Bureau of Prisons 30 days to comply with the mandatory injunction.
From Judge Ricardo Martinez’ order following Judge Christel’s recommendations.
On October 8, the Bureau of Prisons filed an objection to Judge Christel’s report and recommendations, asking the court to either dismiss the case or pause it until a related class-action lawsuit—Kingdom v. Trump, brought by three transgender inmates challenging the Trump administration’s executive order banning gender-affirming care in federal prisons—is resolved.
“The defendants respectfully request that the Court dismiss Buckingham’s claims without prejudice—or, in the alternative, stay them pending resolution of the class claims in Kingdom v. Trump—and deny Buckingham’s motion for a preliminary injunction,” the filing stated.
Buckingham’s attorneys quickly countered, urging the court to uphold Judge Christel’s recommendations.
“Judge Christel correctly found that Ms. Buckingham has shown evidence of a serious medical need, that the BOP was aware of this need but failed to provide appropriate care, and that her ongoing distress and suicidal ideation constitute irreparable harm,” their response read. “Defendants have shown no hardship in providing the necessary consultations, nor have they offered valid grounds to stay or dismiss the case.”
The court has not yet ruled on the Bureau’s objection, but the preliminary injunction is likely to be reaffirmed. If Buckingham ultimately receives his requested “gender affirming” cosmetic procedures, it could mark one of the first successful challenges by a transgender inmate to the Trump administration’s executive restrictions.
The establishment’s supposed love of democracy ends exactly when democracy—as expressed by the popular vote—stops loving the establishment.
And so, with the AfD looking increasingly likely to gain power in one or more German states after next year’s elections—especially in Saxony-Anhalt, where it recently crossed the 40% mark in a regional poll for the first time—mainstream figures are preparing to make it as difficult as possible for the party to govern. That is, if they can’t simply strip the AfD of its hard-won power altogether.
Politicians are considering destroying documents before the opposition enters office, and even handing state power to (mainstream) federal officials. And they are so convinced of their righteousness that they don’t mind discussing these options in public.
SPD Bundestag member Sebastian Fiedler said over the weekend that “if the scenario becomes reality after all and the AfD achieves an absolute majority in a federal state … we have a massive security problem!”
The Democrats can prevent it.
He added, “I’d rather hit the delete button” than hand over sensitive data—such as police and domestic intelligence information—to “extremists.”
The AfD has, of course, seen through this phoney ‘pro-democracy’ rhetoric, responding that when officials “openly toy with the possibility of breaking laws to combat an undesirable party, that is not protecting democracy, but rather yet another abuse of democracy by the SPD.”
Party spokesman Ringo Mühlmann added that far from being a “trivial offense,” withholding or deleting data would be a flat-out crime.
But this hasn’t put officials off. In fact, some have gone further, with Junge Freiheitpointing to discussions around the possibility of an AfD-run state government being stripped of its power “for the first time in the history of the Federal Republic,” meaning the state would instead be governed by a representative of the federal government, “a so-called state commissioner.”
Geert Wilders blew it when he quit the Dutch government in June, thereby precipitating last week’s snap election. That doesn’t mean the populist right is in trouble – quite the opposite.
Wilders ostensibly withdrew his party, the Freedom Party (PVV), from the four-party government because he was frustrated his coalition partners were not going far enough on his signature policy, immigration restriction. But naked political calculation might also have been behind his decision, as polls showed the most moderate party in the coalition, the New Social Contract, had lost almost all of its support.
He could reasonably have thought that a new vote would return PVV to power without the need to compromise as much with a group that only joined him grudgingly.
That hope was foiled, though, by a few developments. First, all of the other coalition parties said they would not form a coalition with him again. Dutch voters who wanted dramatic change knew then that a vote for Wilders would likely be wasted.
Wilders was also hurt by the defection of one of his prominent members, Ingrid Coenradie, to another conservative populist party, JA21. The party immediately spiked in the polls and rose to as many as 13 seats in pre-election surveys before winning a record high nine seats.
Yet another right-populist competitor, Forum for Democracy (FvD), also changed its leadership before the vote. Long-time leader Thierry Baudet elevated a 28-year-old woman, Lidewij de Vos, to lead the party’s list. FvD also gained seats, capturing 7.
Finally, Wilders’ own campaign decisions likely hurt him. He avoided all of the early debates, only joining the fray in the campaign’s final days. This backfired as his opponents all ganged up on him in the final debates, depriving him of the chance to repeat his rapid, final week ascent from two years ago.
The result was that PVV dropped from 37 to 26 seats. But the combined total for the country’s four conservative populist parties – PVV, JA21, FvD, and the Farmer-Citizen Movement (BBB) – only declined by two seats, from 48 to 46 in the 150-seat chamber.
That total is still nearly one-third of all seats, a near record high for the Dutch Right. The total is even higher if one adds in the centre-right Party for Freedom and Democracy (VVD) and the ultra-Calvinist SGP. These six parties hold 71 seats together. No working government can be formed without at least one, and probably more, of these parties.
That could happen, as the Dutch left suffered serious losses. The GreenLeft/Labour Party (GL/PvdA) alliance lost five seats, leading its leader, Franz Timmermans, to resign. The far-left Socialist Party also lost ground while other minor left-leaning parties stayed level.
In 2012, the Labour Party alone won 38 seats while other clearly leftist groupings won an additional 21. This year the entire left won a mere 30 seats.
This means that no Dutch government can be formed without significant right-leaning input. A centrist-focused government including the election’s narrow victor, Democrats 66 (D66), and the revitalised centrist Christian Democrats (CDA) could garner only 66 seats if it joined VVD. The centre needs partners – and VVD has ruled out sitting in government with GL/PvdA.
That leaves JA21 and perhaps BBB as the junior partners that comprise the next government. BBB has only a few seats but has a strong position in the powerful Dutch Senate; adding it to the other four parties would give the centre-right alliance 37 of that chamber’s 75 seats as well as a slim majority in the more powerful House.
The strong populist showing means that Dutch politics has shifted significantly rightward. For decades, Dutch politics tilted to the left, as the Labour Party and other leftist groups vastly outnumbered parties to VVD’s and CDA’s right. That balance has now completely moved, as the right tail is over 50 per cent larger than the left wing.
Wilders and PVV may not be the beneficiaries of this development. If JA21 does join government and can show it was effective, it could grow at PVV’s expense. That would likely be good for the broader conservative populist movement, as the ultimate goal of politics is to wield power, not make statements.
But Wilders and PVV could easily rebound if VVD goes back on its word and allies with GL/PvdA, or if a centre-right government proves too weak to enact at least rightist policies. He could then tell Dutch voters “I told you so” at the inevitable next vote and urge them to break the deadlock by giving PVV so many votes it would have to dominate a new government.
Either way, populism gains in the Netherlands. That, not Wilders’ seeming failure, is the real takeaway from the vote. It’s likely only a matter of time until the Dutch fully join Europe’s populist parade.