French municipal elections: No national left-wing alliance but local deals done

In France’s municipal elections, candidates have until tonight to decide whether to merge lists, run independently, or withdraw before the second round on March 22.

In several major cities, the race is extremely tight, including in Marseille and Toulouse.

It is in this context that, on the evening of March 15, the leader of the Socialist Party (PS), Olivier Faure, reiterated his refusal to form a national alliance with the left-wing party La France Insoumise (LFI).

The LFI has recently been embroiled in several controversies, including criticism over anti-Semitic remarks and positions taken by its leader, Jean‑Luc Mélenchon.

Former French president François Hollande also called on socialists not to unite with the party.

Yet yesterday evening, during an interview on France 2’s main news broadcast, Faure said he “fully understands” the choice made by some PS candidates to form alliances with LFI lists in cities such as Nantes, Toulouse and Limoges.

He maintained that “Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s words damage, divide and weaken the Left” but argued that local LFI candidates should not automatically be held responsible for those remarks.

“If I lived in Toulouse, I would vote for François Piquemal,” Faure added, referring to the LFI candidate who came second in the first round with 27.5 per cent of the vote. A merger between Piquemal’s list and that of PS candidate François Briançon, who finished third with 25 per cent, has since been confirmed.

Faure reiterated that no national agreement had been reached between the PS and LFI “because of Jean-Luc Mélenchon’s statements”. He acknowledged, though, the reality of local deals.

“I fully understand the choices being made in some cities,” he said, referring to agreements between local PS and LFI candidates.

The PS leader added that he would intervene if any candidate involved in such alliances had personally made anti-Semitic or unacceptable remarks. “In that case, I would take responsibility and ask for that list to be suspended,” he said.

This apparent shift has triggered criticism across the political spectrum.

Politicians from the centre, the Right and the far-right quickly condemned the situation.

Bruno Retailleau of The Republicans denounced what he called “shameful agreements”.

Meanwhile, Marine Le Pen of the National Rally (RN), on X accused the Left of “hypocrisy,” saying it was only trying to “save its mandates”.

For Gabriel Attal of the Renaissance party, these were “not local agreements but a national one in disguise”.

Despite these controversies, the PS has remained firm in some key cities. In both Paris and Marseille, where tensions with LFI were particularly strong during the campaign, PS candidates refused to form alliances with the party ahead of the second round.

In Paris, PS candidate Emmanuel Grégoire declined any deal with LFI, potentially opening the door to a comeback from Rachida Dati (Les Republicains, a liberal-conservative party).

In Marseille, outgoing mayor Benoît Payan also rejected an alliance with LFI.

Meanwhile, in Lille, LFI finds itself isolated after the announcement of a PS–Green agreement aimed at countering the party’s local momentum.

All eyes are now on voter turnout for the second round.

Local elections in France are particularly important, especially with the presidential election approaching next year. Potential presidential candidates will need the sponsorship of at least 500 mayors to run, making control of municipalities a key political asset.

brusselssignal

German police report 15-year-old boy was murdered by ’23-year-old German’ without mentioning he is a dual Turkish citizen

The crime took place outside this supermarket in Eckernförde. REWE Stein – Google Maps

In the investigation of the fatal assault on a 15-year-old boy in Eckernförde, authorities have taken a “23-year-old German” into custody, per official police statements. Following an inquiry by German newspaper Nius, it was clarified that the individual in question is a dual citizen, holding both German and Turkish nationality.

The joint investigation by the Kiel public prosecutor’s office and local police led to the identification of the man as the primary suspect. He is currently accused of manslaughter following a violent altercation outside a supermarket on March 11, 2026.

The teenage victim suffered severe injuries during the encounter and later passed away.

On Tuesday morning, a formal press release was issued regarding the arrest of the “23-year-old German” suspect. When contacted for further details by Nius, a spokesperson for the Kiel police confirmed via telephone that the suspect maintains dual German and Turkish citizenship.

The incident took place in the immediate vicinity of an Eckernförde supermarket. Following his arrest, the 23-year-old was presented to a judge at the Bremen District Court later that afternoon. An arrest warrant was subsequently issued, and the suspect is currently being held in pretrial detention.

As reported by Remix News in the past, dual citizens and German citizens with a migration background are widely distorting crime data, as the case of clan gangs in Germany reveals. In many German states, if a dual citizen commits a crime, the crime is simply listed as “German.” A number of states have now taken steps to increase reporting of crimes involving these dual citizens to deliver clearer and more transparent data.

It remains unclear if the suspect’s dual citizenship in this specific case would have ever been made public if it were not for Nius.

Notably, Schleswig-Holstein’s Minister-President Daniel Günther had ignited a fierce national debate following an appearance on the German talk show “Markus Lanz,“ earlier this year, where he advocated for a social media ban for minors and stricter “quality criteria” for media outlets.

Specifically, he cited Nius news portal, stating their articles, “there is usually nothing right in it,“ and that their work is “completely devoid of facts.“ He called for stricter media quality control.

His comments have drawn accusations of authoritarianism and threats to constitutional freedoms from across the political spectrum.

rmx

‘Islamist Entryism’ Into Britain’s Deep Gives Government ‘Systematic Bias’ on Middle East, Says Former Ambassador

Britain’s deep state government is in the clutches of “strange topsy-turvy morality” that treats allies as enemies, in part because of “Islamist entryism” into the Civil Service, a former diplomat has warned.

There is “systemic bias” against Israel and the British government’s paralysis over the Middle East is seeing it burn away its hard-won global influence, a former ambassador has claimed in an article for a British broadsheet. Edmund Fitton-Brown, formerly of the Foreign and Commonwealth Office (Britain’s foreign ministry) from 1984 to 2017 and now a senior fellow at the U.S.-based Foundation for Defense of Democracies warned in the Daily Telegraph that structural issues with the British Civil Service were partly to blame for these changes, but also that as Britain became an increasingly anti-Semitic country, so too its government changed to reflect the public.

Of these entry points for bias, Fitton-Brown stated: “When you have a couple of dozen posts where Arabic is spoken and only one Jewish state, you train large numbers of Arabic speakers”, and noting ambassadors had always shown a predilection for going native and adopting the interests of the cultures they so carefully studied for their jobs.

What he called “Islamist entryism” is visible “throughout the Civil Service and a range of other professions”, he said, noting there are “Hate marches for Hamas and the Houthis” in society, and “the Civil Service reflects society”.

On the attitudes now apparent inside Britain’s civil service which has led to elected politicians being repeatedly given bad and harmful advice, Fitton-Brown stated that in the “strange topsy-turvy morality of the Foreign Office, an institution increasingly unsure who Britain’s friends and enemies actually are”, it is “now undeniable that parts of the Civil Service have developed a systematic bias when it comes to the Middle East.”

This bad advice has led to strategic paralysis, Fitton-Brown claimed, stating the present extraordinary spectacle of the British government standing by while its allies move to dismantle a would-be nuclear terrorist state in the Middle East is the result of the nation’s leadership losing the ability to make friend-enemy distinctions, with catastrophic results for Britain’s international influence. He stated: “a country sitting nervously on the fence, hoping the conflict will pass us by while our influence quietly ebbs away. The Americans have certainly noticed our lack of resolve. Our Gulf allies have looked elsewhere for assistance. We weren’t even there to protect our bases on Cyprus.”

On these consequences, the former ambassador added: “this vacillation is not without cost. We fought for the Falklands, but what happens when a predator next casts envious eyes on our overseas possessions? How do we justify our permanent seat on the UN Security Council if it is ever called seriously into question?”.

The remarks came as the United Kingdom, foremost upon the European allies of the United States, was particularly and repeatedly named by President Donald Trump for its conspicuous failure to play its part in securing the sea lanes of communication in the Middle East to keep the global economic engine running. On this failure to do what is expected of it to keep the oil flowing, President Trump has repeatedly said America called on Britain to deploy its minesweepers — one of the UK’s key contributions to the NATO alliance — only to be rebuffed.

On Tuesday, President Trump was said to be extremely angry, and himself stated in the White House that the relationship with the United Kingdom “should be the best… until Kier came along… he doesn’t produce.”

breitbart

Belgium: army to secure Jewish institutions following wave of antisemitism in Europe

The Belgian defense ministry, in cooperation with the federal police, has taken responsibility for securing sites connected to the Jewish community in Belgium, announced Interior and Defense Ministers Bernard Quintin and Theo Francken.

The decision comes following last week’s attack at the Liège synagogue, where an explosive device detonated, and amid antisemitic incidents in Norway and the Netherlands.

Soldiers will be deployed to synagogues and Jewish schools “as soon as possible,” according to the ministers. Operational aspects will be managed by the police in close cooperation with the defense ministry. It is not yet clear how many military personnel will be deployed.

“In light of rising antisemitism, the attack on the Liège synagogue has once again shown that the threat to the Jewish community in Belgium is very real,” said Minister Quintin.

On March 9, an explosion occurred near the synagogue in Liège. A few days later, incidents took place in Rotterdam and Amsterdam, including a fire set at a synagogue and an explosion at a Jewish school. In Norway, the day before, an explosion occurred at the US embassy.

Michael Freilich, a Jewish parliament member who advocated for the deployment of soldiers in Jewish areas, wrote: “The federal police have called on the army to protect Jewish sites now, while the threat is real. It is good to finally see action being taken following a series of attacks on Jewish institutions. This step is important. Safety must come first.”

Following the attack in Liège, several political leaders called for military deployment to ensure security in places frequented by many Jews. The coordination committee of Jewish organizations in Belgium also called for soldiers to be deployed on the streets.

israelnationalnews

UK: TV chef has announced her cookery show has not been renewed by the BBC for being ‘too Muslim’

Nadiya Hussain worked with the BBC for the best part of a decade | BBC

Ulrika Jonsson has hit back at Nadiya Hussain’s claims that she was dropped by the BBC for being “too Muslim,” dismissing the claims in a no-holds-barred column.

The television presenter, who has worked in broadcasting for 38 years, wrote that being Muslim was categorically not the reason Ms Hussain lost her cookery programme.

“I beg your pudding?” Jonsson sarcastically quipped in response to Ms Hussain’s assertions.

She argued that television has undergone a significant transformation, with diversity now properly represented on British screens following decades of campaigning.

“Diversity is finally on the menu and it is a much healthier portrayal of our modern society,” Ms Jonsson stated.

The former Gladiators host added that as a white middle-aged woman, she has accepted taking “a backseat” to make room for greater representation.

Ms Jonsson pointed to claims that had emerged suggesting Ms Hussain’s departure was linked to uninspiring recipes and reports that she had become challenging to collaborate with.

“No idea if any of that’s true, but it fits with my brief encounter with her,” the columnist wrote.

She recounted meeting Hussain in a television green room years ago, having been excited after watching her win the Great British Bake Off in 2015 alongside her daughters.

“I was disappointed to find her quite dismissive with a seeming sense of entitlement about her,” Ms Jonsson alleged, writing in The Sun.

The 57-year-old went on to caution “fame-hungry” individuals who achieve sudden celebrity status that stardom is never guaranteed to last.

“Most will be very lucky, indeed, if it lasts longer than 15 minutes,” she observed.

Ms Jonsson acknowledged that Ms Hussain possesses cooking talent and appeal, but insisted the television industry owes her nothing.

“I don’t sit at home with my pity pot wondering why I’m no longer being ‘chosen’,” she wrote as she drew parallels with her own career trajectory.

The columnist described Ms Hussain’s public complaints as “embarrassing” and delivered a pointed suggestion.

“Perhaps she would consider shutting her cakehole before she alienates people even more,” Ms Jonsson concluded.

She emphasised that change remains constant in the entertainment world, with tastes evolving and new personalities continually emerging.

“Many good things come to an end,” she noted, adding that reality television stars frequently see their appeal fade when it “lacks longevity.”

Ms Jonsson’s comments come after Ms Hussain spoke out in recent weeks about her BBC departure, telling one interviewer she dreamed of cooking on television into old age like Mary Berry but felt this was impossible because she is “not white.”

The 41-year-old, who won the Great British Bake Off in 2015, said Muslim women in television lack longevity and described feeling like “a token” whose space eventually disappears once “the box has been ticked.”

She also claimed to The Guardian that she receives lower pay than white presenters performing equivalent roles.

“I get paid less to do the same job as the white version of me,” Ms Hussain stated.

Good Morning Britain presenter Adil Ray was one public figure who offered an opposing view to Ms Jonsson’s.

Along with Countryfile’s Anita Rani, ITV Lorraine doctor Amir Khan, and a few others, the Good Morning Britain presenter publicly backed her claims, suggesting it was a “sad reality” for many in the industry.

GB News has contacted Ms Hussain’s representatives for comment.

gbnews

Belgium PM Bart De Wever Defended Restoring Relations With Russia and Buying Their Cheap Energy – and Now the Whole Globalist Establishment Is Turning on Him

PM De Wever from Belgium did the unthinkable in today’s Europe: put his citizens’ welfare above political considerations.

De Wever is under pressure for saying an obvious truth – but the voters are with him.

In Globalist, decadent Europe, whatever you do, you can’t put the needs of your population above the political narrative of the day.

So, when Belgian Prime Minister Bart De Wever’s suggested that the EU should negotiate with Russia and buy their cheap energy, he sent waves across the old continent.

De Wever’s enlightened suggestion has put him in collision course with Globalists at home and abroad.

Politico reported:

“Speaking to L’Echo, Belgium’s leader made the case for a deal to ‘normalize’ relations with Moscow to regain access to cheap energy, as costs spiral thanks to another war in the Middle East. 

Opposition politicians reacted furiously, while parties within De Wever’s government were also quick to distance themselves. Belgium’s ruling coalition required 236 days to negotiate a detailed reform agenda, and their ongoing disagreements have repeatedly turned into public quarrels.”

What De Wever said is verboten, since the EU demands all its members to be rabidly anti-Russia, and doesn’t want a discussion on how its own energy sanctions are hurting itself.

“De Wever’s comments also come after a nationwide poll last week revealed he enjoys widespread support, with the Flemish-nationalist leader’s popularity not only at a record high in Dutch-speaking Flanders, but also growing in French-speaking Wallonia. The strong polling may help explain the prime minister’s willingness to push a politically sensitive argument.”

Euronews reported:

“The European Union remains divided on the issue. French President Emmanuel Macron, Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni and Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán have called for direct talks with Moscow, while Poland and the three Baltic states are firmly opposed.

‘In private, European leaders agree with me, but no one dares to say it out loud. We must end the conflict in the interest of Europe, without being naïve towards Putin’, De Wever said. At the same time, we must normalize relations with Russia and regain access to cheap energy. That is common sense’, De Wever said.

[…] ‘Given that we are unable to pressure Putin by sending weapons to Ukraine, and cannot suffocate his economy without US support, only one method remains: making a deal’, he said.”

thegatewaypundit

BRAZIL: Trans-Identified Male Politician Who Attempted to Have Women’s Rights Activist Imprisoned For “Misgendering” Him Chosen to Lead Women’s Rights Committee

A trans-identified male politician who previously attempted to have a woman imprisoned for “misgendering” him was elected as president of the Women’s Rights Committee. Felipe Santos Silva, who has adopted the name Erika Hilton, told the Chamber of Deputies that the Committee should focus on women “without exception in their dignity and plurality,” and included transvestites in his definition.

“We will discuss projects here, we will discuss the lives of women here, we will remember that, whether they like it or not, cis women, trans woman and travestis [transvestites] will not be abandoned in this discussion, and I don’t care about anyone’s wishes,” Hilton, of the Socialism and Liberty Party, stated.

In Brazil, the Commission for the Defense of Women’s Rights (Comissão de Defesa dos Direitos da Mulher) – is a standing committee in the Chamber of Deputies. Its members are responsible for evaluating legislation and public policies related to violence against women and issues that impact women’s health.

The decision was celebrated on Reddit forum r/MTF, where men who claim to be women said Hilton’s appointment was “fantastic” and “epic.”

Upon accepting the role of President of the Women’s Rights Commission, Hilton blasted his critics as “LGBTphobes” and “defenders of pedophilia.”

On March 11, the same day he was elected to the position, Hilton filed a criminal complaint against TV presenter Carlos Massa, widely known as Ratinho, for questioning his appointment to the Women’s Rights Commission. On the Sistema Brasileiro de Televisão (Brazilian Television System – SBT), Ratinho criticized the decision, stating, “I didn’t think it was very fair… why give [the role] to a trans woman?” He also remarked that Hilton “is not a woman.”

“I have nothing against trans people,” Ratinho said. “For a woman to be a woman, she has to have a uterus.”

The claim against Ratinho and SBT, filed with the Public Prosecutor’s Office of São Paulo, accuses the presenter of “transphobia, transphobic slurs,” and “gender-based political violence.” Hilton is demanding $10 million Brazilian reals, the equivalent of $1.9 million dollars.

“What the presenter committed was violence, an attack, and it wasn’t just against me,” Hilton wrote in a social media post. “Ratinho interrupted his program to say that trans women aren’t women, that women who don’t menstruate aren’t women, that women who don’t have a uterus aren’t women, and that women who don’t have children aren’t women. This attack from Ratinho was against all trans women and against all cis women who no longer menstruate or never have.”

“He and SBT will pay for their actions, in the civil and criminal spheres,” he continued. “And they won’t pay me, but all women victims of violence, trans and cis. Finally, it’s worth remembering: I am and always will be a woman. This presenter is, and always will be, a rat.”

But Ratinho is not the only individual who has faced criminal prosecution for declining to “validate” Hilton.

As previously reported by Reduxx, feminist activist Isabela Cêpa faced criminal charges lodged against her by Hilton in 2021.

Hilton was elected to São Paolo’s municipal government in November of 2020, winning his seat by a landslide that gave him the title of the most voted-for ‘woman’ in Brazil.

At the time of his victory, Hilton was celebrated in international media as being a “symbolic triumph” for transgender people. Hilton was amongst the top 10 most-voted for candidates in all of Brazil, and was touted as the “only woman” to make the list.

“At the time I didn’t even know who this person was. I just saw a headline on an Instagram page celebrating that ‘the most voted woman in São Paulo is a transwoman,’” Cêpa told Reduxx. “Then, I shared a video with my followers saying I was disappointed to hear that the most voted-for woman in São Paulo – later found out that it was in the entire country – was a man.”

Hilton didn’t report Cêpa to police until November of 2021, and in January, police arrived at Cêpa’s mother’s workplace to ask for her whereabouts. After speaking with police, Cêpa did not hear about the status of the complaint until June 2022, when she was contacted by a reporter seeking comment for an article.

It was at that time that Cêpa learned she was being charged with 5 counts of “social racism” after the Public Prosecutor combed her social media feed to find other “transphobic” statements. In total, Cêpa was facing 25 years in prison for calling Hilton a man.

In 2019, Brazil’s Supreme Federal Court ruled that discrimination against ‘LGBTQ Community’ constituted a penal offense, but fell under existing race-based protections as a form of “social racism.” This came a few years after State Police in São Paolo began to include trans-identified males in “femicide” statistics.

Last year, Cêpa was granted full refugee protections by the European Union Agency for Asylum. The previous year, 2024, Cêpa had been stopped by at the Salvador Bahia Airport while attempting to travel to Spain to visit a friend. Federal agents flagged an alert linked to her passport and pulled her aside for further inspection. During the subsequent interview, authorities reportedly determined that her situation could meet the criteria for political persecution.

In June of 2025, Cêpa formally applied for refugee status, which she was granted – making her the first Brazilian citizen to receive this designation for state persecution since 1985.

In September 2025, Justice Gilmar Mendes rejected Hilton’s complaint against Cêpa, and in the ruling, stated that calling Hilton a “man” does not constitute a hate crime.

In December, women’s magazine Marie Claire named Hilton as one of it’s “women of the year.” Hilton was called “one of the most influential voices of her generation” and praised for his “initiatives that expand rights, rethink work models and put women and trans people at the center of discussions on welfare, citizenship, equity and access.” His persecution of Cêpa and threats towards other feminists was not mentioned.

As previously reported by Reduxx, multiple Brazilians have faced criminal charges for statements or commentary deemed “transphobic.” Earlier this year, women’s rights activist Karen Mizuno revealed she had been notified by police that she may face criminal charges after mocking a trans activist who claimed that “archaeologists are transphobic.” Mizuno faces up to three years in prison.


reduxx

Concerns in Europe over Another Migrant Crisis Amid Conflict in Iran

Still grappling with the civilizational transformations of the migrant crisis sparked over a decade ago by conflict in the Middle East, the European Union is facing the prospect of another large wave, with little more in the way of protection for its external borders.

In 2015, more than a million migrants poured into Europe as German Chancellor Angela Merkel unilaterally opened the gates of the bloc to mass migration from Africa and the Middle East, most notably from the Syrian Civil War, which in part was exacerbated by U.S. involvement, with the Obama administration funding rebel groups against the now-defunct regime of Bashar al-Assad.

The influx of the largest number of alleged asylum seekers since the Second World War upended European society and politics radically, sparking crime waves in once peaceful nations like Sweden, ingraining Islamist terrorist movements across the continent, straining national budgets, and entrenching sectarian politics.

Characteristic of the bureaucracy-obsessed European Union, it took a decade for the bloc to reach a form of migration agreement, dubbed the Migration and Asylum Pact, which is still only set to come into force by June. Even this agreement was struck over the objection of conservative nations such as Hungary and Poland, given that its primary aim is to share the burden of migration equally throughout the EU, meaning that countries which fail to police their borders can send illegals to countries that do, upon threat of financial penalties from Brussels.

It is unclear if the Migration Pact will be able to function regardless of outside pressure, with it already facing the prospect of Viktor Orbán’s Hungary refusing to abide by the terms of the deal and it being fundamentally undermined by the socialist government of Pedro Sánchez offering amnesty to illegal migrants, who in turn will be granted legal status throughout the internal open border Schengen Zone, a development likely untenable for many fellow member states.

Meanwhile, debate in the EU Parliament continues on the subject of so-called offshore “return hubs”, which would see illegals immediately removed to detention centres outside of the European Union rather than being allowed to remain within EU borders while their asylum claims are processed. Conservatives such as Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni have argued that such sites are necessary to deter further illegal migration and to make deportation systems effective, given that only around one in five illegals are actually sent back to their homelands per year.

On top of the continued arrival of hundreds of thousands of illegals every year, the EU is now bracing for potential migrant crises to be sparked by the conflict in the Middle East, with both Iran and Lebanon currently under fire from the United States and Israel.

In a letter to member state leaders ahead of this week’s European Council summit, Commission Chief Ursula von der Leyen admitted that Brussels is concerned over the prospect of fresh waves of mass migration.

“Although the conflict has not yet resulted in immediate migration flows towards the EU, what the future holds remains uncertain and requires the full mobilization of all migration diplomacy tools at our disposal. It is therefore crucial to work with countries in the region, such as Turkey, Lebanon, and Pakistan,” she wrote, according to Italy’s Il Giornale newspaper.

Von der Leyen noted that other areas may see a rebound in the number of migrants fleeing to Europe, saying that “worrying developments are being recorded along the Central and Eastern Mediterranean routes, with a sharp increase in departures from Libya.”

Others have expressed concern as well, including Swedish Migration Minister Johan Forssel, who told POLITICO last week that  “a new refugee crisis … is not an option for us.”

“We are still seeing the consequences of what happened 10 years ago. And that’s not just the situation in Sweden, but I would say elsewhere in Europe too,” he added.

Nicholas Ioannides, deputy migration minister of Cyprus, which has come under direct fire from Iran during the conflict, warned that the EU “cannot overlook the possibility of a new refugee crisis,” adding that it “might test [the] effectiveness of the bloc’s new rules.”

Even prior to the conflict with Iran, there were concerns over the potential of a new migrant crisis from the region, with a report from the EU Agency for Asylum (EUAA) written before strikes began, warning of an “unprecedented” level of migratory flows if war broke out in Iran.

“With a population of approximately 90 million, even partial destabilisation could generate refugee movements of an unprecedented magnitude,” the report said. “Displacement of just 10 per cent of Iran’s population would rival the largest refugee flows of recent decades.”

breitbart

EU’s top court rules all 27 member nations must recognize ‘transgender’ identities

On March 12, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) issued a landmark judgement ruling that all 27 EU member states must now create a functioning process for so-called “Legal Gender Recognition” (LGR) so that citizens exercising their EU right to move to a different country can be issued identity documents that match their “lived gender.” The judgement asserts the supremacy of EU law over national laws.

Specifically, the judgement targets countries such as Hungary, Slovakia, and Bulgaria, which do not permit the changing of sex on official IDs and reject the premises of gender ideology.

The case, C-43/24 Shipova, was brought by a transgender-identifying man in Italy, who has been trying for a decade to get his name and gender changed on official documents. The Bulgarian courts have denied this requests. In 2023, the Bulgarian Supreme Court issued a binding interpretation stating that lower courts cannot permit LGR; this followed a 2021 Constitutional Court ruling affirming that “sex” is biological and that the LGBT concept of “gender” does not exist in Bulgarian law.

The CJEU, however, claimed that this violates the EU right of freedom of movement within the 27 member states, and that denying citizens the right to change their sex on official documents creates “considerable inconveniences” while traveling and attempting to live out their “gender identity” in other countries and demanded that member states submit to demands of transgender activists. The judgement further stated that laws banning LGR is a denial of the “dignity and freedom” of gender-confused Europeans.

The CJEU also ruled that Bulgaria’s ban on LGR was a violation of the “right to private life” upheld by Article 7 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights, even though the case in question was not about how a transgender-identifying person lived his or her life in private, but rather whether the government accepted the premises of gender ideology and formally recognized people’s chosen identity on official documents.

The ruling comes as no surprise; the European Court of Human Rights has been targeting Bulgaria’s national laws for years, most notably in 2020 in the “Y.T.” case and in 2022 in the “P.H.” case, both of which stated that Bulgaria was in breach of the European Convention on Human Rights for refusing to facilitate LGR. Additionally, in September 2024, Advocate General Richard de la Tour stated in an opinion that EU member states are obligated to provide LGR to gender-confused citizens.

LGBT groups are pleased with the decision. ILGA Europe noted that the CJEU “also updated its earlier interpretation of EU gender equality law and its applicability to [so-called] trans people. The Court said that ‘to tolerate discrimination based on the difference between biological sex and gender identity’ would violate [gender-confused] persons’ respect for their dignity and freedom, which the Court has a duty to safeguard.” It is not yet clear how this might apply to other national laws that reject the premises of gender ideology.

LGBT activists are already working to build on this decision.

“As a result of today’s ruling, all pending cases in Bulgaria must be resumed without delay, and courts and authorities must issue judgements in accordance with EU law and the CJEU’s ruling in the Shipova case, said Denitsa Lyubenova of the LGBT organisation Desytvie.

At the same time, a serious legal gap remains. Bulgarian citizens who have not exercised their right to free movement are still left without an effective legal pathway to change their personal data. This highlights the urgent need for legislative reform to ensure effective protection of trans people living in Bulgaria.

“For the first time, the CJEU has interpreted EU law as requiring Member States to legally recognise ‘lived gender identity,’” stated Adina Portaru, senior counsel at Alliance Defending Freedom International. “In doing so, it sidelines national constitutional protections of biological sex and narrows Member States’ competence over their own civil-status laws.”

In a statement posted to X, ADF International called the ruling “yet another attack on national competence and sovereignty” and noted that “When courts use back-door arguments, such as free-movement law, to reshape national civil-status rules, as they did in this case, it raises serious concerns about both democratic accountability and the protection of biological sex in law.”

lifesitenews