British daily The Times demonises PM Modi and India for not supporting draconian Sharia

The Times published a report saying UCC will overturn sharia law in India

On Tuesday, February 6, the Uttarakhand government tabled the much-awaited Uniform Civil Code (UCC) in the state assembly.

The bill included various provisions, including a complete ban on polygamy and child marriage, a standardised marriageable age for girls across all faiths, and a uniform process for divorce. These proposals, geared towards promoting gender equality and social harmony, will be discussed during the ongoing special four-day assembly session, which commenced on Monday and will run until Thursday.

The draft of the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) covered a wide range of aspects of civil life. It includes suggestions regarding inheritance rights, compulsory marriage registration, and raising the legal age of marriage for girls to enable them to pursue education before marriage. Moreover, couples who do not register their marriages will not qualify for government benefits, signalling an emphasis on legal documentation.

The proposed UCC aims to establish uniform civil laws applicable to all communities within the state and end the complex labyrinth of individual laws that govern different communities, which presents challenges to the uniform enforcement of legislation that is the cornerstone of a secular society.

As the Uttarakhand government tabled the Uniform Civil Code (UCC) Bill in the state assembly on Tuesday (February 6) for discussion, The Times, a British national daily, found an opportunity to perpetuate its longstanding anti-India campaign, vilifying the Modi government and stoking fears among its Muslim population with unfounded claims and patently misleading conjectures.

The headline is a dead giveaway that The Times was up to its mischievous ways to undermine the Indian government and pressurise it to drop the Uniform Civil Code. The Times published an article titled ‘India prepares to pass a law overturning Sharia in ‘Muslim crackdown”, giving a false impression that Muslims remain under a constant threat of persecution in India.

Not only is the headline evidently erroneous since the bill was not tabled in the parliament and by the central government. Instead, it was proposed by a state government for discussion in a state assembly. In their zeal to defame India, The Times and its author went with a headline and a featured image of PM Modi to imply that democratic polity has given way to authoritarianism and the Modi government is moving to pass a law aimed at ‘clamping down’ at its Muslim population.

The preposterous headline naturally created quite a flutter on social media, with several social media users criticising the British daily for characterising the Uniform Civil Code, a set of rules that forms the bedrock of secularism, as a tool of ‘Muslim crackdown’. Facing fierce online backlash that could and should invite legal repercussions for The Times in India, the British newspaper quietly amended the headline and redacted ‘Muslim crackdown’ from its headline.

The Times changed the headline and removed ‘Muslim crackdown’ from it


But it maintained the anti-India and irrational sentiment of the article in its body. Paradoxically, The Times and other Western media houses that routinely hold forth on the need to save ‘secularism’ in India, perhaps out of their historical habit of suppressing Indian consciousness and preventing India from shaping its destiny based on its moral compass, was concerned with the neutering of Sharia law with the introduction of the Uniform Civil Code.

Here’s how The Times rhapsodised the Sharia Law:

The relevant section from The Times article on UCC


If the above paragraph is anything to go by, The Times was not only supporting Sharia Law, but it was also going into raptures about the abhorrent practice of polygamy that allows Muslim men to take more than one wife, thereby contributing to their mental and physical health outcomes, including severe depression, anxiety, psychosis, and in some cases, domestic violence too.

The Times also came out in support of another regressive practice called ‘halala’, which according to Islamic customs, is a practice where the divorced wife has to temporarily marry another person, consummate the marriage and get talaq again. It is intimately linked with triple talaq, which has already been invalidated by Indian laws.

The relevant section from The Times article on UCC


The practice reduces women to being a mere commodity that can be discarded by pronouncing ‘talaq talaq talaq’ and then acquired again by undergoing ‘halala’, which involves marrying her to another man, establishing sexual relations with him and then divorcing him if she wants to remarry her first husband.

The evil practice, of course, has a serious bearing on Muslim women and deeply affects their physical and psychological well-being. But it is of little concern for The Times which seeks to ignore these inequities meted out on Muslim women as long as it helps them in mounting their attacks against the Modi government.

The other casualty of The Times’ perversity is secularism in India. The Western media never fails to pontificate India on “secularism” and the need to protect it, even though India has never been a secular country and “secularism” in India’s context has always been pluralism and composite culture, where people espousing different religions not only found refuge but also thrived and their religious practice protected.

However, despite being a staunch advocate of secularism, The Times and the Western media have no compunction in railing against a law that seeks to abolish oppressive individual laws and introduce a set of rules that apply uniformly to all sections of society and treat them as equals regardless of their caste, creed, and race.

Uttarakhand UCC: British daily The Times comes out in support of Sharia Law to malign India (opindia.com)

‘Mr. Bean’ Star Rowan Atkinson Blamed for Slow EV Sales

screen grab youtube

English comedy icon Rowan Atkinson, forever applauded for his on-screen creation Mr. Bean, has been blamed for “damaging” the reputation of electric vehicles (EVs) and contributing to slow sales simply by expressing his opinion on their future – or lack of it.

The actor was name-checked in the British House of Lords on Tuesday during its environment and climate change committee meeting, Sky News reports.

Thinktank Green Alliance outlined the main obstacles the government faces in its bid to push petrol and diesel cars to the kerb before 2035, pointing to a newspaper comment piece by the Johnny English star published in June 2023 as damaging to the cause.

The pressure group told peers in a letter an opinion piece by Atkinson damaged the cause of EV take-ups. The missive read in part:

One of the most damaging articles was a comment piece written by Rowan Atkinson in The Guardian which has been roundly debunked.

Unfortunately, fact checks never reach the same breadth of audience as the original false claim, emphasising the need to ensure high editorial standards around the net zero transition.

The 69-year-old actor’s piece was headlined: “I love electric vehicles – and was an early adopter. But increasingly I feel duped.”

Atkinson wrote EVs were “a bit soulless” and criticised the use of their lithium-ion batteries, as Breitbart News reported.

He suggested solutions like drivers keeping the same car for longer periods of time and increased use of synthetic fuel would negate the need for EVs, saying: “Increasingly, I’m feeling that our honeymoon with electric cars is coming to an end, and that’s no bad thing.”

Atkinson further noted greenhouse gas emissions created in the production of an electric car were 70 percent higher than in the manufacturing of a gas car due to the use of lithium ion batteries.

“They’re absurdly heavy, huge amounts of energy are required to make them, and they are estimated to last only upwards of 10 years. It seems a perverse choice of hardware with which to lead the automobile’s fight against the climate crisis,” Atkinson wrote.

The Guardian struck back a week later with comment from Simon Evans, deputy editor and senior policy editor of climate news site Carbon Brief, which looked to debunk Atkinson’s claims by taking on an actor who has always been a strong proponent of free speech.

Evans wrote: “Atkinson’s biggest mistake is his failure to recognise that electric vehicles already offer significant global environmental benefits, compared with combustion-engine cars.”

Atkinson’s views were used to make a wider point about allegedly “misleading” reports stunting EV sales.

Other challenges highlighted during the committee meeting included insufficient numbers of charging points, higher prices on EVs and “a lack of clear and consistent messaging from the government.”

Overall sales of EVs are defying the combined urging of green lobbyists and government diktat with just a quarter making up new purchases for 2023, UK data reveals.

Aside from a lack of electric charging stations and consumer nervousness over reliability, the unit cost of EVs coupled with rapid depreciation remain among the prime reasons consumers are giving for sticking to petrol-powered cars.

https://www.breitbart.com/entertainment/2024/02/07/mr-bean-star-rowan-atkinson-blamed-for-slow-ev-sales/

Media accused of ‘downplaying’ size of migration protest in Ireland

screen grab youtube

Mainstream media outlets have been accused of “downplaying” the size of a recent anti-mass migration protest in Ireland.

Despite numerous claims that more than 1,500 people attended the demo – a considerable number for Ireland – numerous mainstream publications reported figures far lower than that.

According to multiple major news outlets, only a “few hundred people” attended the anti-immigration protest in Dublin city centre on February 5, although the figures reported by each vary considerably.

According to The Irish Times, around 700 people were at the main protest despite attendees’ claims there were more than 1,000. The Irish Independent wrotethere were as few as 500 present at the demo.

Other outlets put the number at in excess of twice that, with state broadcaster RTÉ saying the figure was around 1,000, while the Cork-based broadsheet The Irish Examiner put the figure at about 1,500.

One reporter from The New York Times even claimed on social media on the day that the size of the counter-protest was “much larger” than the main event.

That caused uproar among many online, with even the most conservative crowd-size estimates from mainstream media publications having the primary protest substantially outnumbering any counter-demonstration.

By contrast, publications more closely aligned with the Right put the number of attendees as much higher than the mainstream estimates.

Online publications Gript and The Burkean both claimed the numbers as being in the thousands.

Speaking to Brussels Signal, spokespeople for the NGO Migration Info Ireland also claimed that the number taking part was substantially higher than what was published by Ireland’s mainstream media, citing video evidence.

“Last year’s anti-racism rallies saw an exaggerated portrayal in the media, while anti-migration protests were downplayed,” they said on February 6.

“Video footage and images from yesterday’s demonstration clearly depict a crowd exceeding 1,500 people,” they added, saying that both the Irish Government and media now needed address migration by “acknowledging its existence”.

“The Government and media must earnestly address and engage with people’s concerns around migration and facilitate resolution,” they concluded.

https://brusselssignal.eu/2024/02/media-accused-of-downplaying-size-of-migration-protest-in-ireland/

Swedes Protest State Broadcaster’s Liberal Propaganda

Outraged citizens in Sweden have vented their anger at the state broadcaster for being politically biased and misleading its viewers. In a protest held on Saturday, around a thousand people marched to the headquarters of the public broadcaster to express their dissatisfaction with the reporting of Sveriges Television (SVT) and Sveriges Radio (SR).

The organisers of the protest argue that serious problems faced by society are concealed or treated inappropriately by the broadcaster, while harmful and extreme ideologies are being promoted, and alternative media and its representatives are smeared or excluded from the public discourse.

“This harms Sweden as a nation. We do not want Sweden to be governed by extreme ideologies or international interests,” the organisers state, calling for objective reporting and a more diverse spectrum of opinions on topics such as the adverse effects of vaccines, NATO, migration, climate, and gender issues.

The organisers also want to end taxpayers’ obligation to finance the broadcaster. As of January this year, Swedish citizens have to pay a maximum licence fee of 1,219 Swedish kronor (€107) per year, or 1% of their income. Swedes are obligated to pay the fee regardless of whether or not they have a television set.

The protest coincides with the growing dissatisfaction with one-sided public media broadcasts all around Europe. In a debate in the Austrian parliament last week, Herbert Kickl of the right-wing opposition party FPÖ criticised the centre-right-green government for introducing a modified version of the previous licence fee, which now means that every household has to pay a fee of €15.30 per month, even if they do not possess a television set. Failure to register, or supplying false information, could carry a fine of up to €2,180.

Kickl accused the government of introducing yet another new tax in an era of economic crisis, one that would be used to fund state propaganda. The public broadcaster, ORF, he said, was lacking in both objectivity and independence. He added that his party was a frequent target of the ORF and that they would abolish the tax were they to enter government. Austria is set to hold elections in autumn, and the FPÖ is on course to win around 30% of the votes, although it is unlikely they would be able to form a coalition with any of the other parties.

A similarly negative sentiment towards public media services is being felt in Norway. According to conservative outlet Document, people are turning their backs on the public broadcaster NRK’s daily evening news programme, Dagsrevyen, which has lost 140,000 viewers in the past four years. NRK is criticised by many for being politically biased in favour of the Left, and for talking positively about issues such as the green transition, diversity, multiculturalism, and immigration.

In the United Kingdom—the home of public service broadcasting—500,000 households cancelled their TV licences last year. This allows them to avoid paying the hefty fee of £169 per year, but some would seek to avoid financing the BBC, which seems less focused on entertainment and impartial information than on liberal progressivism and diversity.

https://europeanconservative.com/articles/news/swedes-protest-state-broadcasters-liberal-propaganda/

Left-wing extremist attack on the Collegium Hungaricum building in Berlin

Antifa stunned

The cowardly attack by the left-wing extremist Antifa is in all likelihood connected to the devious and extremely brutal attacks against completely uninvolved people carried out by the international Antifa thugs in Budapest a year ago. In addition, the left-wing thugs, who are usually treated with great leniency by the judiciary in Germany, are unlikely to forgive the fact that such offences are severely prosecuted in Hungary. In addition to the attack on the building of the Hungarian Cultural Institute, the international left also launched a smear campaign against Hungary and its prison conditions.

On the evening of 26 January, the building of the Collegium Hungaricum in Berlin was attacked by the extreme left: „#honourless“ signs were sprayed on the walls of the institution and several windows were smashed. (mandiner)

Antifa hate letter

In the hate-antifa statement, the attack is explained with the criminal trial against German and Italian antifascist thugs that has just taken place in Hungary:

„Our solidarity goes to the antifascists* arrested last year because of this and to those wanted in this context, which we express with the attack. In the case of international smear campaigns, intimidation by the repressive authorities and presumably imminent extraditions, we cannot stand by in silence, but must take a stand. In the case of the international smear campaigns, intimidation by the repressive authorities and presumably imminent extraditions, we cannot stand by in silence, but must actively intervene in what is happening. It is not enough just to attack the Nazis and their structures; the right-wing think tanks and media acceptance procurers of the supposedly superior European culture are also legitimate targets. The trial in Budapest begins on 29 January – let’s show those affected that they are not alone and let’s show the German judiciary and the Hungarian state that we will not remain inactive! „

Against Hungarian migration policy

In addition, in the usual Antifa hate jargon, there was also incitement against a discussion event on Hungarian and German migration policy, which took place in the German-Hungarian Friendship Association, with the participation of the Hungarian Chancellery Minister Gergely Gulyás at the time, in October 2023 in the Collegium Hungaricum.

Interesting because it exposes the Orwellian distortion of reality of the antifa fascists and their fear of the alternative media: In addition to the discussion about a tougher stance towards travellers seeking protection and the stricter sealing off of Europe, the focus was on the racist discourse on „imported anti-Semitism“ that is also taking place here and the alleged threat posed to Europe by migration.

Unsurprisingly, the press invited to the event were Junge Freiheit and Tichys Einblick. According to Junge Freiheit, the evening was introduced by the President of the German-Hungarian Society, Gerhard Papke. He said of Budapest:

„There is no murderous Allahu Akbar shouting on the streets there. Hungarians don’t let people like that into their country. They are smarter!“ The Hungarian state is a driving force and important partner when it comes to promoting murder and the sealing off of the EU borders and has also been conducting a racist campaign against Sinti*zze and Rom*nja in its own country for a long time.“ Obviously, the international Antifa thugs are attacking Hungarian institutions because the Hungarian judiciary punishes such inhuman acts with the full force of the law. And does not tolerate them – as is the case in Germany, for example.

https://unser-mitteleuropa.com/130524

Spanish Farmers Join the European Agricultural Revolt – Promised Concessions by the EU Have Not Stopped the Movement

The old continent is in a trance ahead of the June European Parliament elections, that are poised to give populist, right wingers more power than ever.

Add to that the fact that farmers are staging unprecedented protests all across the continent, from east to west, from north to south.

A non-exhausting list would include France, Netherlands, Poland, Romania, Portugal, Greece, Ireland, Italy, now Spain, and of course Belgium – with farmers converging to Brussels to protest in front of the European Parliament.

Such a threat to the Brussels bureaucracy it poises that Commission President Ursula von der Leyen appeared to cave big time to some of the farmers’ demands.

But meanwhile, the farmer revolt is still spreading like wild fire – now in Spain.

Spanish farmers today (6) blocked traffic on several highways and burned tires.

They join other European countries in protesting against high costs, bureaucracy, competition from non-EU nations and – MSM loves to forget that – the failed, crippling ‘green’ regulations.

BBC editor received payment to help Somali criminals, including a gang rapist, to fight deportation from the UK

A BBC editor allegedly helped at least 15 Somali criminals including a gang rapist fight deportation cases and remain in the United Kingdom, as per British media reports. According to the reports, the BBC editor was hired as an expert witness to help these Somalian criminals in their deportation cases. 

The African Editor of BBC World Service, Mary Harper was paid to give expert evidence for Yaqub Ahmed, a Somali gang rapist, as reported by Telegraph. 

According to an investigation by The Mail, it was found that the BBC Editor gave expert witness evidence in a series of other controversial deportation appeals by Somali offenders as well. These include three other sex attackers, three drug dealers, and a career criminal who had spent a decade in British jails.

As per the report, in one incident, BBC Editor Mary Harper reportedly warned that the criminal’s repeated history of committing crimes in the UK would lead to his ostracisation by his clan if he was deported back to Somalia. Notably, the criminal had faced 39 convictions for 80 crimes over 17 years. 

In another case, Harper reportedly warned that a 29-year-old Somalian sexual offender would be at “severely heightened risk” if he was deported back to Somalia as he had committed a sex crime. The Somalian accused had sexually assaulted a deaf girl who was 17 years of age.  

However, his appeal against deportation was rejected by a judge who disagreed with the argument presented by BBC Editor Mary Harper. 

According to the newspaper, some 16 months later, the attacker remains in the UK and has been living in a council flat with his family. Reportedly, the identification of the attacker has been prevented by law.  

However, the BBC announced that Harper was leaving the organisation. It is understood that she will depart from BBC later this month. Her most recent role at the BBC was that of a journalist reporter. It is still unclear whether she quit the job or was sacked by the media corporation. 

The details surfaced when a refugee, accused of orchestrating a chemical assault that wounded a mother and child, was rejected for asylum twice before eventually being granted permission to remain in the UK, claiming that he had converted to Christianity.

A nationwide manhunt was launched to apprehend Abdul Shokoor Ezedi (35) who arrived illegally in the country in the back of a lorry in 2016. He claimed that his life would be in danger if he was deported back to his native place, Afghanistan.

In 2018, he was found guilty of a sexual offence. Although his asylum plea was purportedly turned down twice, he was permitted to stay following an endorsement from a priest who affirmed his conversion and asserted that he has complete dedication to his newfound faith.

A Home Office spokesman said, “Foreign national offenders have no right to be in the UK, which is why we are deporting them and banning their return to the UK. Over 16,000 Foreign national offenders have been removed since January 2019. Through both our Nationality and Borders Act and the Illegal Migration Act, we are also ensuring they cannot frustrate the removal process.”

The BBC, on its part, separated itself from the “external work” of its staff. The media corporation argued that they are not against anyone acting as expert witnesses, they only need to get prior approval for it.  

A BBC spokesman said: “While there is nothing in the BBC’s rules that prevent staff acting as expert witnesses, the BBC has clear processes in place to ensure any external work of this nature has prior approval. We are unable to comment on the specific details of this particular case and, more broadly, do not comment on individual staff matters.”

Meanwhile, there was no response from Harper to a request for comment.

Details of Ahmed’s case

Yaqub Ahmed, the Somali gang rapist whom the BBC editor allegedly helped, dragged a five-year legal battle to remain in the UK. He was deported from the country in November after 15 years only after agreeing to pay for his hotel and therapy. 

He was sent to jail in 2008 after he and along with his three accomplices lured a minor girl to a London flat before attacking her. During the proceedings, a judge lambasted Ahmed for having “no respect for other human beings”. In 2015, then-Home Secretary Theresa May had subsequently stripped his refugee status and handed him a deportation order. 

However, a lot of legal battles took place, even going up to the Court of Appeal, where government lawyers fought off three attempts by the rapist and his legal team to challenge the decisions. As reported by The Mail earlier, Ahmed’s legal, prison, and deportation costs ended up costing taxpayers up to £1 million.

BBC editor hired to help Somali criminals fight deportation from UK: Report (opindia.com)

Sex worker would ban Arabs from brothels because they are ‘aggressive,’ says Germans are her best customers

Wikimedia Commons , Arne Hückelheim, CC-BY-SA-3.0

A sex worker who migrated from Romania to work in Germany says the first thing she would do if she were the boss of the brother is to ban Arabs, saying they are “aggressive,” according to an interview from left-leaning Der Freitag newspaper.

In the interview, the journalist asks, “What would you change if you were the boss of the club?” The woman responds, “Wow, a lot. Firstly, I would no longer let the Arab men in. They are aggressive. Second, I would raise prices (for customers).”

She also says that Germans are her favorite customers, saying “They treat us with respect. That makes my work easier.”

The interviewer appears to take umbrage with this statement and says, “But don’t you really despise them? Be honest.”

She responds: “I despise them when they put their wives down, when they say, ‘My wife totally sucks in bed,’ because they want me to feel special.”

Overall, she says she feels safe in her working environment but finds nothing she likes about her job. She also notes that she has a boyfriend who lives back home in Romania, but she sends nothing home to him, as he earns his own money.

Despite her desire to ban all Arabs, she complains that she faces discrimination in the job market because she is a dark-skinned Roma.

When asked about getting a “normal” job, she says it is not possible: “First of all, you have to speak German well, otherwise they won’t take you. Second, because I’m brown, they wouldn’t take me anyway,” she claims, despite numerous retailers hiring brown-skinned employees across Germany.

When the interviewer expresses skepticism, she says: “Come with me to Rossmann (drug store), you’ll see it there. I was there the other day, and the security guy was standing right behind me while I was trying on perfume. With the tester! I got nervous and asked him, ‘What are you doing?’ He said, ‘My job.’ I said, ‘No, your job is not to have my back.’ I have never stolen in Germany. I pay taxes.”

However, she also says she is not from a “gypsy” family but one with strict rules. “We don’t get married young. We live like normal Romanians. But because we have a slightly brown skin color, we are “gypsy.”

When the interviewer asks her why she does not take social assistance back home and not be a sex worker in Germany, she also says that in her home country, social assistance is available, but complains that Ukrainian refugees get to go to the front of the line.

“Yes, there is. But you have to wait years if you want an apartment. However, not if you are a Ukrainian refugee. It’s also bad if you get sick. Even if you have health insurance, you can’t expect the doctor to even look at you unless you give him ‘extra.’” she said.

The interview offers interesting insights into sex work in Germany, which is legal, but which has been a controversial topic in recent years.

Is Germany’s legal prostitution policy keeping crime rates down?

Legal prostitution in Europe has been shown in studies to reduce rape rates compared to those countries that do not legalize prostitution. The argument is that the young men most likely to partake in rape can gain sexual release in a legal manner through a pool of prostitutes. An influx of primarily young men from Africa and the Middle East has already shown in European crime statistics to be highly overrepresented in terms of rape, gang rape, and sexual assault compared to other populations. As a result, in countries like Germany, legal prostitution may actually be keeping the crime rate for sexual crimes from being even higher than it currently is.

As Germany moves towards giving migrants benefit cards instead of just cash, one of the unforeseen consequences could be a reduction in these migrants’ ability to pay for sex with German taxpayer money. Although taxpayers may cheer the news, at least some of these migrants may turn towards seeking sex through violent and illegal means.

https://rmx.news/article/roma-sex-worker-would-ban-arabs-from-brothels-because-they-are-aggressive-says-germans-are-her-best-customers/

“I will behead you all”: An acquaintance of the terrorist from Arras, France, was arrested for justifying the attacks on Charlie Hebdo and Samuel Paty

An 18-year-old acquaintance of Mohammed Mogushkov, the Arras assassin, was sentenced to social care on Tuesday for glorifying terrorism.

As part of the investigation into the murder of literature teacher Dominique Bernard, who was stabbed to death on 13 October 2023, Dani M., a young man with no criminal record and a thick red beard, came to the attention of investigators.

[…]
“We are not dealing with a provocation here, but with someone who is expressing his convictions,” said the public prosecutor, whose motions were followed.

The five-year supervision imposed in Arras is linked to a training and supervision obligation as well as 210 hours of community service. Dani M. faces up to two years in prison if he fails to comply. However, the young man did not say anything about his relationship with Mohammed Mogushkov during the hearing.Le Parisien

« Je vais tous vous décapiter » : une connaissance du terroriste d’Arras (62) interpellé pour avoir justifié les attentats contre Charlie Hebdo et Samuel Paty (Màj : Condamnée à un suivi socio-judiciaire et des travaux d’intérêt général) – Fdesouche

Mrs. Gates and Mrs. Jobs Make a Racism Movie – America is bad. Obsessing over race is good

Origin, the movie, claims to be about the origin of racism in America, but its own origin story lies with the Ford Foundation, Laurene Powell Jobs, the widow of Steve Jobs, the Apple guru, and Pivotal Ventures, the nonprofit started up by Melinda French Gates after she dumped Bill Gates, which provided much of the money needed to fund the $38 million smear of the United States.

What kind of movie would two wealthy woke white women fund? A pop history take on racism.

Origin is based on Caste: The Origins of Our Discontents, another one of those 2020 books about a racial reckoning of the kind that Mrs. Jobs and Mrs. Gates would have encountered in book clubs and while browsing The Atlantic (Mrs. Jobs owns it) or Slate (Bill Gates used to.)

Isabel Wilkerson, the protagonist of book and film, is another one of those critical race theory ‘public intellectuals’ with a media platform, a former New York Times bureau chief, who stars in it because it follows her deep thoughts about race which unroll with the depth and sophistication of a college freshman browsing Wikipedia while pulling an all-nighter to turn in a midterm paper.

Like Between the World and Me by Ta Nehisi Coates or Ibram X. Kendi’s How to be an Anti-Racist, Caste tried to pretend that its familiar and simplistic premise, (‘America is racist’) had some kind of depth by inappropriately linking it to other people’s historical experiences, the Holocaust and the caste system in India, while filtering it all through Wilkerson’s deep thoughts.

Trayvon Martin, Wilkerson’s personal life and Nazis goose stepping through Berlin all get mixed up in some intersectional tangle of narrative oppressions in both book and movie. Wilkerson taking plane trips to Germany or India allows her to bag up and appropriate two very different sets of histories to bolster her own feelings of oppression as a New York Times bestselling author.

The premise was thin enough in book form, but it’s downright absurd to make a writer into the protagonist of a movie because she’s reading about things that happened to other people and then flying off to other countries to study and listen to things that happened to other people..

And then makes it about herself.

What makes a New York Times bureau chief married to a white man into a victim? Wilkerson’s secondary trauma comes from listening to tapes of the Trayvon Martin case. What a violent encounter between a Latino man and a black teen has to say about racism in this country is dubious already, and even more dubious when it’s someone entirely unrelated to the case writing about dealing with the trauma of hearing about it.

But Caste, the book, like most literature of this kind, is about feelings, not facts, and Origin, the movie, adds yet another layer to this palimpsest in which we are seeing an actress portraying a writer who is writing about something that she did not see and was not even witness to. Origin might have dropped the baffling hall of mirrors and just cut to a documentary clumsily tying together disparate historical events in Germany and India, or in Wilkerson’s own memories, but this is an Ava DuVernay project and the Selma director clearly wanted to make a movie.

While the premise may be absurd, the contents are even more so. Only using Wilkerson as the ‘My Truth’ focus holding the narrative together makes it seem like it has any credibility. A good storyteller can weave together different stands to make them seem like they hold together, while a bad one compensates for her failings with special pleading and calls for sympathy.

Wilkerson, who has spent a whole lot of time in the company of the kinds of woke white women who would buy her books and fund the film, understood that what they really wanted was her emotional journey and the history would always matter less than her pain. And she delivers it. Her mother is dying, her husband is dying and she’s writing about racism in America.

That the subjects of her personal pain have nothing to do with her indictment of America is besides the point. The point of ‘My Truth’ narratives is that anecdotes trump history and that the only meaningful currency in a woke society is the emotional unburdening of personal suffering.

Caste was already bad history. The book promoted the idea that the Holocaust was a result of American racism because the Nazis had gotten some ideas from racial eugenicists in this country. While that’s passingly true, German antisemitism had a long history before America even existed. The Nazis put together a grab bag of ideas all over the place, including Marxists, pagan folklore and the Thule Society which believed that there was a secret inner world inside a hole in the planet, not to mention appropriating a Buddhist symbol for their swastika because they were obsessed with Tibet and the secret origins of the Aryans over in that part of the world.

Long before intersectionality, the Nazis were the original intersectionalists, gluing together random pieces of history, economics, politics and myth into an intellectually inconsistent mess that served their political purposes. That is also the shape of Origin’s scrambled eggs history.

Wilkerson’s misreading of the role of caste in India, the thing that gives her book its title, is equally wrong, but, like the Holocaust, all of human history is just a grab bag of oppression narratives to build to the conclusion that racism in this country is a permanent institution with deep roots in history, rather than an ugly accident from an era where everyone who was at all different was viewed with prejudice overlapping with the temporary export of the ruinous practice of slavery, which had been long suppressed in Europe from Africa and the Middle East.

Racism in America is not a permanent institution, but that the Left has labored to make it one.

The essence of critical racial theory or anti-racism is the idea that racism is inescapable and that it permeates everything, an “original sin”, as Obama put it, that we cannot escape except by adopting the leftist ideology and policies of Mrs. Gates, Mrs. Jobs and the Ford Foundation..

Caste and Origin provide false historical props that misattribute the true origins of the persistence of racism in America. It’s not white racists who cling bitterly to a caste system, but the DEI industry and its voluntary beneficiaries who mandate the caste system and oppose any efforts, such as the Supreme Court decision striking down affirmative action, to end it.

It’s no coincidence that the title of the movie was changed from emphasizing Caste (an insulting idea) to Origin. From the 1619 Project, another work of historical revisionism from another New York Times reporter, to ‘Stamped from the Beginning: The Definitive History of Racist Ideas in America’, the book that first made Ibram X. Kendi famous, there is an obsession with creating a revisionist origin story of racism to justify the myth that things are just as bad as they ever were.

Origin lacks the bleakness and malicious racial antipathy of Between the World and Me and How to be an Anti-Racist, the former so defined by its hatred of white people that Coates actually wrote that the police officers and firefighters who died on September 11 “were not human to me. Black, white, or whatever, they were menaces of nature; they were the fire, the comet, the storm, which could — with no justification — shatter my body”.

There are moments of understanding and hope in Caste  even if they are based on the author’s insistence on her own victimhood. In the movie, Nick Offerman, a liberal Democrat who ever since playing Ron Swanton on Parks and Recreation built a career playing a liberal’s idea of a right-winger, shows up as a rude plumber in a MAGA hat only to open up to Wilkerson.

That condescending otherness is still more open to the humanity of others than much of the critical race theory which insists on the absolute evil of white people and ‘whiteness’.

America is not defined by racial castes and the invocation of a MAGA plumber reveals far more about Wilkerson’s actual caste and her perception of working class white conservatives. It’s not a racial prejudice, but a class one, that she shares with the wealthy woke white women who read over her volume in their book clubs, and will flock to indie theaters to catch the movie.

The country’s true caste system is that of coastal, urban and suburban laptop elites who condescend to the rest of the country. Its origins are too complicated and messy to fit in an easy pop history template like the 1619 Project or Caste, but they reflect displacement, economic turmoil and a seizure of power in the name of ideology that comes with personal benefits.

Those benefits include New York Times bestsellers and movie deals, and when Hollywood won’t fund a movie, a few nonprofits flush with money from dubious fortunes, will pay the bill.

To find the real caste system, don’t look at race, look to the wealthy woke institutions that dominate the high ground of American culture and media.

https://www.frontpagemag.com/mrs-gates-and-mrs-jobs-make-a-racism-movie/