
French Socialists are pushing to legalize an estimated 300,000 illegal migrant workers, embracing the same mass regularization agenda as Spain’s failed Socialist prime minister Pedro Sánchez despite an explicit warning from the EU that such policies encourage further illegal immigration.
The proposal is endorsed by the party’s presidential candidate, Raphaël Glucksmann, who declared during an October primary debate: ‘We will do it, and it will be popular.’ He also urged his fellow Socialists to ‘stop being afraid of the diktats of the National Rally on this issue,’ referring to Marine Le Pen’s party and its hard-line anti-immigration position.
Introduced on 6 October by Socialist MP Paul Christophle, the bill would grant a residence and work permit as a legal entitlement to foreigners able to prove at least six months of employment within the preceding two years. The periods need not be consecutive, and employment could be demonstrated by any means, creating a breeding ground for potential fraud. Crucially, applicants would not face the current shortage-occupation route’s three-year residence requirement or its 12-month employment threshold.
The Socialists present the measure as protection against exploitation. However, there is a much more troubling message behind such policies: work illegally for six months, and France will reward you with legal residence.
The bill praises Sánchez’s April mass regularization policy as a model to follow. The scheme was initially expected to cover around 500,000 illegal migrants but attracted 1,174,978 applications by the end of June. Spain’s programme primarily relied on prior residence rather than France’s proposed employment test; both, however, would offer legal status on a mass scale.
Sánchez’s move had already received substantial backlash from the European Union. On 28 October, the European Commission confirmed that it would examine a complaint from the Catalan independence party Junts alleging irregularities in Madrid’s implementation of the scheme. While no formal infringement procedure has yet been launched, the possibility of one is clearly there.
Both the Spanish and French initiatives run directly counter to a longstanding European commitment dating back to 2008, when EU governments agreed to favour individual rather than generalized regularizations. The European Parliament recently reinforced that position on 17 September, voting 339–225 to condemn Sánchez’s policy as a ‘pull factor’ and warning that ‘illegal entry must never become a shortcut to legal residence’.
The underlying cause of the resolution was the mass invasion of Ceuta, Spain’s North African enclave, where around 80,000 illegal migrants crossed from Morocco at the end of July. The EP explicitly described the incident as an ‘invasion’ and warned that mass-regularization signals could embolden migrants and smuggling networks.
‘Both the Spanish and French initiatives run directly counter to a longstanding European commitment’
In France, nevertheless, the proposal faces substantial parliamentary obstacles. Even if the Socialists secured the backing of Mélenchon’s far-left France Unbowed, the Greens and the Communist-aligned alliance, the combined left would command just 193 seats in the 577-seat National Assembly, leaving it dependent on support or abstentions from centrist parties. Resistance from the National Rally and the parliamentary right, alongside a conservative-dominated Senate, makes the bill’s passage highly unlikely. RN MP Laurent Jacobelli rejected the proposal outright, declaring ‘zero regularizations’ and warning that immigration had reached an ‘intolerable’ level.
The bill is scheduled for 19 November, although it may never reach a vote. Meanwhile, Marine Le Pen, who has made opposition to mass immigration a central pillar of her political agenda, leads virtually every major poll ahead of France’s 2027 presidential election. Recent surveys consistently place the National Rally leader between 32 and 37 per cent, well ahead of her competitors. An October OpinionWay poll put Le Pen on 36 per cent against Glucksmann’s 13 per cent, highlighting the stark contrast between their competing visions for France’s immigration policy.









