Catholic Civil War: “Doctrinal development” vs. historic teaching

Among all the words written about Pope Francis’ effects on the Catholic Church, one picture succinctly illustrates the existential conflict American Catholics face.

The Rev. Joseph Devlin, a pastor in suburban Philadelphia, tweeted a picture of a book in his trash can. The foreword for the book, The Synodal Process is a Pandora’s Box, was written by Cardinal Raymond Burke, the former archbishop of St. Louis. Burke, who questions Francis’ theological positions, warned about an upcoming international synod that proposes fundamental changes to historic teaching.

“Where this belongs!” Devlin tweeted. “I stand with and trust Pope Francis.”

American Catholics find themselves caught in the crossfire of a war between those, such as Devlin, who blindly support the pope and those, such as Burke, who legitimately question the direction in which Francis is leading the church.

Burke’s camp includes Bishop Joseph Strickland of Tyler, Texas, who issued a pastoral letter Aug. 22 on the synod, which plans to address the sacramental status of remarried and divorced Catholics, gender ideology and ecumenism, at least.

“The evil and false message that has entered the church … is that Jesus is only one among many, and that it is not necessary for his message to be shared with all humanity,” Strickland wrote. “This idea must be shunned and refuted at every turn.”

Strickland then briefly presented the historic teaching on the subjects mentioned before declaring that “the surest footing we can find is to remain firmly upon the perennial teachings of the faith,” he wrote.

Before Strickland issued that letter, Francis expressed contempt for his conservative American critics while meeting with Portuguese Jesuits on Aug. 5. Civilta Cattolica, a Jesuit magazine edited by the Vatican, printed his remarks Aug. 28, six days after Strickland’s warnings.

“There is a very strong reactionary attitude,” Francis said. “It is organized and shapes the way people belong, even emotionally. I would like to remind those people that indietrismo (being backward-looking) is useless and we need to understand that there is an appropriate evolution in the understanding of matters of faith and morals as long as we follow the three criteria that Vincent of Lérins already indicated in the fifth century.

“In other words, doctrine also progresses, expands and consolidates with time and becomes firmer, but is always progressing. Change develops from the roots upward, growing in accord with these three criteria.”

The term “faith and morals” holds special significance for Catholics, who believe papal teaching on such subjects is infallible.

So, Francis uses Vincent’s criteria to justify his theological novelty. But what are those criteria and do they apply?

Cardinal John Henry Newman, a 19th century British convert, popularized and refined Vincent’s criteria in An Essay on the Development of Doctrine. Newman devised seven tests: 1) preserving the type or identity 2) continuity of principles 3) assimilative power 4) logical consequence 5) anticipation of its future 6) conservative action and 7) chronic vigor.

Newman used a biological analogy to explain the first test: “Young birds do not grow into fishes, nor does the child degenerate into the brute (animal), wild or domestic…” Concerning his second test, Newman wrote that “a development, to be faithful, must retain both the doctrine and the principle with which it started.”

Assimilative power means that “a living idea becomes many, yet remains one,” Newman wrote. His fourth test determines whether a doctrine “is likely to be a true development, not a corruption, in proportion as it seems to be the logical issue of its original teaching.” Newman’s fifth test involves “early imitations of tendencies which afterwards are fully realized … in accordance with the original idea,” he wrote.

The sixth test requires faithful progress without contradictory change, with Newman directly citing Vincent on that point, while the seventh concerns doctrinal longevity.

The problem is the pope’s subtle yet direct contradiction of Catholic teaching, as FrontPage Magazine often reported. The Rev. Juan R. Velez, a doctor of dogmatic theology and an expert on Newman, used the cardinal’s third test to criticize proposals that open the possibility for divorced and remarried Catholics to receive communion, a possibility that repudiates historic teaching.

“The proposed doctrine seems to assimilate the Christian practice of mercy and forgiveness, but it contradicts others such as justice with regard to the obligations that derive from the nature of marriage,” Velez wrote in Catholic World Report in 2014. “It is doubtful that it can pass the test of assimilative power.”

Two years later, Francis wrote Amoris Laetitia, a papal exhortation that appeared to do what Velez feared. Burke and three other Vatican cardinals formally asked Francis to explain his rationale — and have yet to receive an answer after seven years. Since then, two of the cardinals have died.

When it comes to such subjects as gender ideology and abortion, Francis plays a double game. On the one hand, he offers lip service to historic teaching. But on the other, he appoints and supports Catholics who publicly disown that teaching.

Take gender ideology. As FrontPage Magazine often reported, Francis calls gender theory “ideological colonization” yet appoints such men as the Rev. James Martin and Luxembourg Cardinal Jean-Claude Hollerich to important positions. Martin, a papal communications advisor, not only uses social media to promote gender ideology, including sexual transition for children. He even criticized biblical condemnations of homosexuality on Twitter.

Hollerich, appointed to Francis’ closest circle of advisors in March, went further. He publicly rejected Catholic teaching on homosexuality.

Or take abortion. As FrontPage Magazine often reported, Francis equates having an abortion to “hiring a hitman,” yet embraces and supports American and European politicians who support legalized abortion. Among them are Joe Biden and Rep. Nancy Pelosi, who identify as Catholics.

In 2021, as head of the former Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, Cardinal Luis Ladaria discouraged American bishops from applying canon law and withholding communion from such politicians.

The next year, the head of the Pontifical Academy for Life, Cardinal Vincenzo Paglia, said on Italian television that the Vatican had no interest in opposing a 45-year-old law allowing abortion. Paglia even called the law, “a pillar of our social life.”

In promoting his theological agenda, Francis lets others take the lead — and the immediate risks — while he silently supports them. Once conditions reach critical mass, Francis can embrace the changes as a natural evolution. He demonstrated this exact behavior in 2018 concerning capital punishment.

For centuries, the Catholic Church accepted and defended the death penalty; the Papal States even used it. But in 1995, Pope John Paul II used his encyclical Evangelium Vitae to argue that capital punishment was fundamentally unnecessary. The head of CDF at the time — Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, the future Pope Benedict XVI — changed the catechism to reflect that view.

As a result, Catholicism developed a basically abolitionist stance toward the death penalty. In 2018, Francis solidified that stance by calling capital punishment “inadmissible,” or fundamentally immoral. Once again, authorities changed the catechism. But the Rev. John Hardon, a Jesuit scholar, argued in 1975 in his commentary on the catechism:

“Nowhere in the New Testament is capital punishment outlawed. On the contrary, the New Testament not only recognizes the right of the State to exercise authority in the name of God but enjoins obedience to the State in applying the laws of God to its citizens.”

Hardon’s critique decades before its time not only exposes Francis’ careless handling of theology for his own purposes, using Vincent of Lerins as an excuse. It reveals the utter contempt Francis and his allies have for previous teaching, especially doctrines coming from Scripture.

Ironically, in citing Vincent, Francis actually contradicts him. As the fifth-century monk wrote:

“What, if some novel contagion seeks to infect not merely an insignificant portion of the Church, but the whole? Then it will be his (a Catholic’s) care to cleave to antiquity, which at this day cannot possibly be seduced by any fraud of novelty.”

But the Catholic bishops who take that advice face fierce opposition from their own. In January, as FrontPage Magazine reported, San Diego Cardinal Robert McElroy — whom Francis appointed — argued for “radical inclusion” of LGBTQ Catholics, regardless of their sexual behavior or their views on Catholic teaching about homosexuality. Within a month, Bishop Thomas Paprocki of Springfield, Ill. called McElroy a heretic unfit for church office.

Yet the conflict between Paprocki and McElroy, like the one between Devlin and Burke, reflects the ominous state of the Catholic Church worldwide.

“The present crisis is probably the worst the church has had for centuries, perhaps from its beginning, in some way or another,” said John Rist, a Catholic scholar in Britain. “It’s more dangerous to the existence of the Church. You can compare the Reformation, but I think it’s even more serious than that.

“In terms of the damage that it now might cause, what might happen to the Church in the future, this is going to cause more trouble, more than anything else we’ve seen before.”

https://www.frontpagemag.com/catholic-civil-war/

Germany: Muslim man “incapable of crime” escapes from psychiatric ward and randomly stabs a German woman to death

Ahmad N., Photo police

The African Ahmad N. escaped from the forensic psychiatric hospital in Wiesloch and shortly afterwards killed a 30-year-old shop assistant. The murder now draws criticism against Baden-Württemberg’s Minister of Social Affairs, Manfred Lucha (Greens).

On Friday, the 33-year-old man, who had come to Germany as a “refugee”, used the walk to a “work therapy” to escape from the North Baden Psychiatric Centre. He ran from the hospital grounds into the city centre of Wiesloch. His companions lost sight of him. Even the police who were called could not prevent what happened next.

The violent criminal known to the police apparently randomly stabbed the shop assistant Lisa S. at 1 p.m. The woman, aged 30, was working in the discount shop “Tedi”. The shop is located in the shopping centre “Kubus am Adenauer”. The man, who had been declared not guilty by a court for assault, coercion and insult, had apparently stolen the knife from a bakery beforehand.

The town of 26,000 inhabitants, 13 kilometres south of Heidelberg, is in shock. Many residents laid flowers and lit candles at the scene of the crime. The conditions in the prison are considered unacceptable for the staff. The AfD parliamentary group spoke of “scandalous underfunding of the prison”. Manfred Lucha (Greens), the Minister of Social Affairs, had to “explain to the state parliament how such a disastrous incident could have happened”.

There is a “massive lack of staff and space”, said Florian Wahl, a member of parliament for the Social Democratic Party of Baden-Württemberg. In addition, there are structural deficiencies. The politician made serious accusations against Lucha. He had known about the untenable conditions for years and had not changed the situation. The Social Democratic Party (SPD) has called for a special session of the Landtag on the issue of the prison for the criminally insane.

The police arrested Ahmad N. shortly after the murder under “threat of the use of firearms”. Once again he was not remanded in custody, but returned to the psychiatric hospital. The district judge justified the decision by saying that he assumed that the man was incapable of crime.

https://jungefreiheit.de/politik/deutschland/2023/mord-migrant-gruene/

Trans Teacher Who Rarely Wore Prosthetic Breasts Outside Classroom Now Identifies as Male, Ditches Z-Cups on First Day of School

A Canadian transgender high school teacher has gone viral after wearing a massive set of fake boobs with protruding nipples and short shorts in front of young students.

The teacher, identified as Kayla Lemieux, is a Manufacturing and Technology instructor at Oakville Trafalgar High School in Oakville, Ontario. Lemieux reportedly began identifying as a woman just last year.

A video taken during Lemieux’s shop class, seemingly without the teacher’s knowledge, revealed the absurdity of the fake bust and the completely inappropriate way this teacher is permitted to dress. In the video, which quickly went viral on social media, Lemieux is demonstrating how to use a circular saw.

Germany: Afghan asylum seekers attack and seriously injure participants in CSD parade

CSD Halle, screen grab youtube

They were celebrating for cosmopolitanism and tolerance – and were attacked hatefully.

At the end of the Christopher Street Day (CSD) in Halle, several people were attacked by a brutal group of thugs, one of the victims (41) suffered serious injuries.

According to initial investigations by the police, a group at the Schülershof was approached by four strange men in the evening after the parade and insulted.

According to the newspaper BILD, they were referring to the sexual orientation of the CSD participants, and homophobic insults were made. Then the men started fighting!

“The persons with a southern appearance subsequently attacked the group with punches and kicks,” a police spokeswoman explained. “In the process, a 41-year-old man was so seriously injured that he had to be taken to hospital afterwards. Three other victims were treated at the scene by the ambulance service.”

After the attack, the perpetrators managed to flee. The police immediately launched a manhunt – with success. Officers were able to apprehend two of the suspected thugs while they were still near the crime scene. They were two Afghans aged 16 and 20.

On Saturday, thousands of people took part in the celebration of the CSD for the rights of homosexual and queer people. It is about the acceptance and equal rights of gays, lesbians, bi- and intersexuals as well as trans people. Symbol for this: the rainbow colours.

In Halle, about 2800 people took part in the parade through the city. According to the police, the event was largely peaceful. However, there were repeated insults between participants and about 20 counter-demonstrators.

Christopher Street Day (CSD) in Halle: Teilnehmer von Prügel-Mob schwer verletzt | Regional | BILD.de

Polish film slanders Polish border guards for doing their job

Agnieszka Holland, screen grab youtube

The Polish film director, Agnieszka Holland, who has just taken her new film “Green Border” to the Venice Film Festival, is good at playing the role of persecuted artist because it opens doors at all progressive salons. The anti-Polish message of her film helps too.

At the same time, she objects to anyone taking issue with her or her work. While being prepared to accuse Polish border guards of being criminals, she threatens to sue Justice Minister Zbigniew Ziobro for his criticism of her. 

Her film was controversial right from the outset. This is because its message fits into the Russian narrative by attacking Poland for defending its borders and the inhabitants of the border areas for supposed racism. The film has been made at a time when the international community has recognized that Belarus has deliberately weaponized migrants in order to weaken Europe and cause chaos for the benefit of Russia. 

Russia’s efforts are a provocation that was meant to spark a reaction inside Poland, and Agnieszka Holland has taken the bait. She should not be surprised by the criticism she has now attracted in Poland. 

She has never hidden her hostility towards the right and the present government. She has compared migrants coming into Poland with the plight of the Jews during the Second World War and called border guards “criminals in uniform.” Repeatedly, she has asserted that there is no freedom in Poland. The picture she paints of Poles in her film is one of cowardly informers and people whose xenophobia is essentially a form of paranoia. 

This is why there is outrage at the way she is manipulating what Lukashenko’s operation is about. Justice Minister Zbigniew Ziobro compared her film to the Third Reich’s propaganda films, which portrayed Poles as murderers and criminals. 

That in turn offended Holland who, despite stripping border guards of their dignity with her film, took Ziobro’s words as slander and demanded an apology and over €10,000 to be paid to charity. 

Her tales of artists being persecuted in Poland are becoming tiresome. There is no persecution of artists in Poland. They are free to say what they like and use that freedom extensively. Criticism of Holland’s film is simply a statement of protest against lies and manipulation.

https://rmx.news/poland/polish-film-slanders-polish-border-guards-for-doing-their-job/

Netherlands: 300 Muslims left for jihad since 2012, 90 have returned

“The AIVD keeps track of figures on Dutch jihadists because part of the jihadist threat to the Netherlands comes from this group. According to the intelligence service, they could pose a security risk upon return.”

Then why are they allowed to return? That’s the forever-unanswered question.

Why the Left defends Islamic veils

The Left that arrests pastors who define traditional marriage turns the other way when Muslim women are hidden behind veils or killed

by Giulio Meotti

Iranian dissidents accuse the German giant Bosch of manufacturing and selling Iran the cameras used by the ayatollahs to find Iranian women on the streets who do not wear the veil so they can punish them. Can that be the same Bosch that organizes the pro-LGBT “Pride like a Bosch” on the streets of Europe?

The West has become a cartoon of its own self.

Spain’s equality minister, Irene Montero, said that “all cultures and religions” have ways “of oppressing women” and “disciplining their bodies”. “It happens in Afghanistan, with the right of access to work, education, health, but also in Spain.” So let us send many relativist greetings to Afghan women, whose oppression has now been miniimized to that of Spanish women.

When the coach of the women’s national football team, Luis Rubiales, kissed one of his players and for this reason will see her head roll into the basket of virtues, Minister Montero spoke as if he had just reconquered Kabul: “Sexism is over,” she said.

It goes without saying that these hypocrites have never raised a finger against the honor killings, genital mutilations and the full-face veils that circulate on Spanish streets. El Mundo reveals that forced marriages have increased by 60 percent in Spain.

Mimunt Hamido, the Melilla-born Muslim activist who heads the “NoNosTaparán” platform, tells La Razon: “Political Islam has become strong in Europe. Now racism is confused with Islamophobia and misunderstood multiculturalism does the rest. ‘Islamophobia’ is the magic word to shut your mouth. Everyone is afraid of being labeled ‘Islamophobic’, not just people: governments, cities, media…Orientalism is doing a lot of damage, but cultural relativism much more.”

Could this be why Iranian women exiles in Spain attack the socialist government of Montero&Sanchez for its silence on Iranian girls fighting against the state veil in Tehran?

In Trieste, Italy, sixty women, feminists, ecologists and even some men (perhaps self-identified as men) participated in a flash mob: all in the water, dressed to show solidarity with the Islamic burqini. Meanwhile, in Iran, the mullahs send veilless women to mental hospitals. As was done in the Soviet Union with dissidents. For these women, no progressive flash mob appears.

In France, Samuel Fitoussi recalls this week in Le Figaro, the left is fighting against skimpily clad hostesses in sports competitions (traditional ritual kisses are now prohibited), make-up, hair removal, high-heeled shoes, “manspreading”, “mansplaining” and the “asymmetric distribution” of household tasks. But the same left fervently defends, in the name of “progress,” Islamic dresses of all lengths that literally make women disappear from public space, without knowing their preference..

It remains to be seen whether girls covered in an abaya will be allowed to engage in “gender transition” or wear the abaya every other day if they feel “non-binary”. On the other hand, isn’t the French ecological leader Sandrine Rousseau engaged in the crusade to “deconstruct the white male” and fight against one of her “symbols of virility”, the barbecue? A bit like catcalling on the street, against which they even made a law.

In Finland, the former Interior Minister, Paivi Rasanen, was back in court this week for “incitement to hatred”. Did she perhaps ask to stone a homosexual? No, she quoted the Bible on social media to explain that, as a Christian, she is against gay marriage. On the other hand, has the Birmingham imam who has just explained how to stone a woman from the waist up been indicted for hate speech in England?

No, but Juhana Pohjola, bishop of the Finnish Lutheran Church is accused of “incitement to hatred”. “As a Christian, I do not want and cannot discriminate or despise anyone,” but the same time, he continued, “this does not eliminate the fact that marriage is intended only between a man and a woman. This is what the church has always taught and will always teach.”

The English police will never read the imam his rights because he will not accused of encouraging stoning, but they have arrested 71-year-old pastor John Sherwood for “alleged homophobic comments.”.Sherwood was defining marriage as a relationship between a man and a woman at Uxbridge station, west London. The clergyman was taken away in handcuffs, interrogated, held overnight and released without charges. “I wasn’t making any homophobic comments, I was just defining marriage as a relationship between a man and a woman. I was just saying what the Bible says: I didn’t mean to hurt or offend anyone,” Sherwood explains. “When the police approached, I explained that I was exercising my religious freedom. I believe I was treated shamefully. It should never have happened.”

There are electoral and political reasons behind this schizophrenia. Take Brussels, where the left has just chosen another veiled woman as councilor.

The Algerian writer Boualem Sansal says that “the Islamists have won the battle”. “They have enslaved the left, paralyzed the right and the far right is terrified of being dragged to court for racism and Islamophobia. The victory of the Islamists was possible thanks to the work of some, the cowardice of others, the cunning of the opportunists and the indifference of passers-by.”

Is the European left cowardly, cunning or indifferent? Maybe all three. Or maybe it is busy counting potential votes.

Why the Left defends Islamic veils | ערוץ 7 (israelnationalnews.com)

Our Parasitic New Elite Despises the Working Class. Culture Wars & The Decline of the West

On today’s #NCFWhittle we are joined once again by Professor Doug Stokes, Professor of International Relations at the University of Exeter, and author of the new book “Against Decolonisation: Campus Culture Wars & The Decline of the West”. Following the killing of George Floyd in 2020, a moral panic gripped the US and UK. To atone for an alleged history of racism, statues were torn down and symbols of national identity attacked. Across universities, fringe theories became the new orthodoxy, with a cadre of activists backed by university technocrats adopting a binary worldview of moral certainty, sin and deconstructive redemption through Western self-erasure. In his hard-hitting book, Prof. Stokes surveys these developments for the first time. He unpacks and challenges the theories and arguments deployed by ‘decolonisers’ in a university system now characterised by garbled leadership and illiberal groupthink. The desire to question the West’s sense of itself, deconstruct its narratives and overthrow its institutional order is an impulse that, ironically, was underpinned by a more confident and assured Western hegemony, which is now waning and under great strain. If its light continues to dim, who or what will carry the torch for human freedom and progress? To order Prof. Stoke’s new book please click here: https://www.amazon.co.uk/Against-Deco…

The ‘Climate Emergency’ Is a Hoax

More than 1,600 scientists, including two Nobel laureates, have signed a declaration saying that “There is no climate emergency.” The declaration is unlikely to get any attention from the mainstream media, unfortunately, but it is important for people to know about: the mass climate hysteria and the destruction of the US economy in the name of climate change need to stop.

“Climate science should be less political, while climate policies should be more scientific,” states the declaration signed by the 1,609 scientists, including Nobel laureates John F. Clauser from the US and Ivar Giaever from Norway/US.

The statement adds:

“Scientists should openly address uncertainties and exaggerations in their predictions of global warming, while politicians should dispassionately count the real costs as well as the imagined benefits of their policy measures…

“The geological archive reveals that Earth’s climate has varied as long as the planet has existed, with natural cold and warm phases. The Little Ice Age ended as recently as 1850. Therefore, it is no surprise that we now are experiencing a period of warming.

“Warming is far slower than predicted…

“The gap between the real world and the modeled world tells us that we are far from understanding climate change.

“Climate policy relies on inadequate models
Climate models have many shortcomings and are not remotely plausible as policy tools. They do not only exaggerate the effect of greenhouse gases, they also ignore the fact that enriching the atmosphere with CO2 is beneficial…

“Global warming has not increased natural disasters
There is no statistical evidence that global warming is intensifying hurricanes, floods, droughts and suchlike natural disasters, or making them more frequent. However, there is ample evidence that CO2 mitigation measures are as damag­ing as they are costly.

“Climate policy must respect scientific and economic realities
There is no climate emergency. Therefore, there is no cause for panic and alarm. We strongly oppose the harmful and unrealistic net-zero CO2 policy proposed for 2050. Go for adaptation instead of mitigation; adaptation works whatever the causes are.”

Professor Steven Koonin, former Undersecretary for Science at the U.S. Department of Energy under the Obama administration, current professor at New York University, and fellow at the Hoover Institution, authored the 2021 bestseller, Unsettled: What Climate Science Tells Us, What It Doesn’t, and Why It Matters. In it, he states that what the largely unreadable (for laymen) and complicated science reports say on climate change is completely distorted by the time their contents are filtered through a long line of summary reports of the research by the media and the politicians.

“There are abundant opportunities to get things wrong – both accidentally and on purpose – as the information goes through filter after filter to be packaged for various audiences… It’s not only the public that is ill-informed about what the science says about climate…”

Koonin adds:

“Government and UN press releases and summaries do not accurately reflect the reports themselves… Distinguished climate experts (including report authors themselves) are embarrassed by some media portrayals of the science.”

In a recent interview, Koonin noted that his colleagues’ reactions to his book had been that he should not be telling the public or the politicians the truth about climate change.

“I was taught that you tell the whole truth [as a scientist]. And you let the politicians make the value judgments and the cost effectiveness trade-offs and so on,” Koonin said. He noted as well the immorality of asking the developing world to cut down emissions when so many do not even have access to electricity, and the immorality of scaring the younger generations: 84% of American teenagers believing, as of January 2022, that if climate change is not addressed, “it will be too late for future generations, making some part of the planet unlivable.”

Of course it would be helpful to research what can be done to relieve the problems brought about by man, such as the “hole in the ozone layer,” which is now closing, but climate change is not an apocalyptic emergency and needs to be attended to without bringing devastation to the hundreds of millions of people already in extreme poverty.

The Biden administration, however, appears not to be concerned about the widespread poverty and massive starvation that will be caused by the unavailability of cheap and reliable energy in underdeveloped countries, or the inflation caused by the skyrocketing prices that are crushing Americans “barely able to afford one meal a day”.

These are man-made problems, created by importing expensive (nearing $100 a barrel again) — often dirtier — oil from adversaries of the United States, such as Russia and Venezuela, instead of extracting it far less expensively at home. The Biden administration also does not seem concerned that so long as China and India keep burning coal – the Chinese Communist Party is permitting two new coal-power plants a week, easily cancelling out whatever benefits the US might be providing, and reportedly exceeding “all developed nations combined” in carbon emissions.

The Biden administration also does not seem concerned that it is killing wildlife, sea life and the fishing industry by installing offshore wind turbines along the Atlantic seaboard, or that mandating electric vehicles will throw virtually the entire auto maintenance industry out of work (EVs do not need routine maintenance), or that lithium batteries not only explode but cost thousands of dollars to replace. The administration even wants military equipment, such as tanks, to be electric, as if there were charging stations in the middle of foreign deserts in the event of a conflict. Moreover, according to NBC News, volcanoes, unimpressed with executive orders, “Dwarf Humans for CO2 Emissions.”

The Biden administration does not even bother to act on its own climate findings: In March, the White House released a report about the impact of climate change on the US economy. “Its findings undermine any claims of an ongoing climate crisis or imminent catastrophe” Koonin wrote in July.

“The report’s authors should be commended for honestly delivering likely unwelcome messages, even if they didn’t make a show of it. The rest of the Biden administration and its climate-activist allies should moderate their apocalyptic rhetoric and cancel the climate crisis accordingly. Exaggerating the magnitude, urgency and certainty of the climate threat encourages ill-considered policies that could be more disruptive and expensive than any change in the climate itself.”

But facts will not stop the Biden administration from forging ahead with its radical policies: “I don’t think anybody can deny the impact of the climate crisis anymore,” Biden, commenting on Hurricane Idalia, told reporters at the White House on August 30. “Just look around. Historic floods. I mean, historic floods. More intense droughts, extreme heat, significant wildfires have caused significant damage.”

Never mind that much of climate change is apparently caused by sun flares, about which we can do nothing, and which, unlike commercial industries, do not offer grants; or that major wildfires are, ironically, exacerbated by “environmentalists” for refusing to let tinderbox brush be cleared lest the creatures there be disturbed other than by a wildfire.

Climate expert Bjørn Lomborg suggests that the trillions of dollars needed to address climate change might be put to better use:

“This isn’t an argument to do nothing but just to be smarter. To ensure we can transition from fossil fuels, we need to ramp up research and development to innovate down the price of green energy. We should invest across all options including fusion, fission, storage, biofuel and other sources.

“Only when green energy is cheaper than fossil fuels will the world be able and willing to make the transition. Otherwise, today’s energy prices are just a taste of things to come.”

https://www.gatestoneinstitute.org/19962/climate-emergency-hoax