Scottish driver acquitted after prosecution for muttering ‘racist’ remark to himself in his own car

Illustration. Medforth AI

A Glasgow father has been found not guilty after Police Scotland charged him and the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS) prosecuted him for muttering a racist insult under his breath inside his own vehicle after swerving to avoid a motorway collision.

The man, referred to by the pseudonym Craig, had been driving his four-year-old son home to Glasgow on the M80 following a trip to an amusement park in Falkirk, central Scotland, in April 2025 when another vehicle cut across his path, forcing him to swerve.

Suspecting the other motorist was drink-driving, Craig telephoned the police from his car.

Both vehicles subsequently came to a stop and officers attended the scene.

According to accounts of the incident, police declined to breathalyse either driver but took Craig’s dashcam footage to determine whether any offences had been committed.

A week later, officers returned the footage and informed Craig that he, rather than the other motorist, was being charged with “threatening or abusive behaviour” under Section 38 of the Criminal Justice and Licensing (Scotland) Act 2010, with a racial aggravation.

The offence requires behaviour likely to cause a reasonable person fear or alarm, committed with intent or recklessness. It carries up to 12 months in prison on summary conviction.

The charge was based on dashcam audio capturing Craig muttering the words “smelly black b*stard” under his breath seconds after almost being forced off the road, the Scottish Daily Express reported.

According to the Free Speech Union (FSU), which assisted with his legal defence, the car’s windows were closed, meaning nobody outside the vehicle could have heard the remark.

The other driver was not looking in Craig’s direction and the only other person present was his four-year-old son in the back seat.

The only evidence against Craig was the dashcam footage he had turned over to the police in the hope of seeing the other driver brought to justice, FSU general secretary Toby Young wrote in The Spectator.

When Craig asked the officer reading him his rights how he could be charged for speaking to himself inside his own car, she reportedly replied: “The language was still racist.”

Craig subsequently contacted the FSU, arguing that he was being “prosecuted for a thought crime”. Following a court hearing in early November before a justice of the peace, he was acquitted “within minutes”, the FSU said.

Young, a Conservative peer, condemned Police Scotland and COPFS for pursuing the case.

“Given that our member said these words to himself and no one else, he was found not guilty,” Young said. “But what a colossal waste of everyone’s time. In Glasgow, four out of five burglaries go unsolved, while there were 11 car thefts per 10,000 people in the year to June 2026.”

The case has renewed criticism over the policing of speech in Scotland, where hate crime legislation and public order laws have drawn repeated scrutiny from free-speech campaigners over the threshold for criminal prosecution.

The Hate Crime and Public Order (Scotland) Act 2021 came into force on April 1, 2024. Police Scotland received 7,152 online hate reports in the first week, of which 240 were recorded as hate crimes.

A COPFS spokesperson told the Scottish Daily Express: “It is inaccurate to characterise this case solely as relating to words muttered under a person’s breath. The evidence before the court related to the accused’s wider conduct and circumstances of the incident.

“The decision to prosecute was taken following consideration of all the available evidence and the public interest, and we note the court’s decision.”

brusselssignal

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *