UK ‘conversion practices’ bill blasted by author of landmark gender study

Wikimedia Commons, Elvert Barnes, CC-BY-SA-2.0

Leading religious groups such as The Christian Institute have been warning about the totalitarian nature of proposed “conversion therapy bans” in the U.K. for several years. Now, one of the most prominent medical experts in the country has weighed in – and Baroness Hilary Cass made it clear that the current bill under consideration is “not workable.

Cass is a pediatrician and author of the independent report on “gender identity services,” and her bombshell 2024 review led to the U.K. government’s permanent ban on puberty blockers for minors and repudiated many trans activist talking points. LGBT activist groups attempted to discredit her, and she received so many personal threats that she had to stop using public transportation.

Her latest comments once again put her at odds with LGBT activist groups. Cass told BBC Radio 4 that while she supports banning “conversion practices” in theory, she does not support the current bill. “The challenge is that we have not yet, as far as I can see, got a workable bill,” she stated. At a parliamentary committee, she concurred with critics of the bill, noting that it risked “serious unintended consequences” for both parents of gender dysphoric children as well as medical professionals working with them.

Indeed, the BBC’s coverage of the bill blithely affirms these concerns in their description of the legislation: “Conversion practices are generally described as interventions, treatments or activities designed to change or suppress someone’s sexual orientation or gender identity. This can sometimes happen in religious or family settings and can be very distressing for the person at the centre of it.”

“Should a parent be jailed for a good-faith conversation with their child?” Baroness Kishwer Falkner asked in The Telegraph earlier this month. “Few would say yes. But if the Government’s euphemistically named Conversion Practices Bill is passed, that is precisely the threat that will face not just parents, but teachers, social workers and others seeking to support children who feel distressed about the fact that they are a boy or a girl, or whether they may be gay, lesbian or bisexual.”

The bill, Falkner stated, was drafted for activist groups – and it is dangerous. “It is an unprecedented and unwarranted intrusion into family life, that could jail parents for up to five years for ‘crimes’ such as refusing to use a child’s preferred name, refusing to fund gender reassignment or for seeking, with the best of intentions, to dissuade a child from embarking upon a course of medical intervention that leads to permanent sterility,” she wrote, adding:

Additional problems with the Bill include the lack of any statutory defence beyond a minimal exemption for healthcare, meaning that it would be no defence to say that it was reasonable to carry out a certain course of action. It enables private prosecutions, exposing individuals and charities to malicious prosecutions by activists. And it has no minimum-age limit. With 10 being the age of criminal responsibility, this means children at primary school could be prosecuted for playground conversations.

When Dr. Cass was asked at the Draft Conversion Practices Bill committee if she supported the current bill, she was succinct: “No.” Cass pointed out that therapists working with gender dysphoric youth could be targeted for prosecution under the bill’s vague language referring to “distress to the individual.”

“Therapeutic interactions can be distressing and often are because you’re discussing quite sensitive issues,” she told the BBC. “So if a young person comes away feeling upset, distressed, angry, that might be the result of a quite appropriate therapeutic intervention but still could be judged as poor professional practice. The problem is the chilling effect of professionals knowing that they may be open to complaint, and indeed prosecution.”

In fact, Cass echoed Falkner’s concerns, noting that the proposed bill could even result in the prosecution of parents who refused to give their children money that might be used to purchase cross-sex hormones or “breast binders.”

Cass told the Draft Conversion Practices Bill committee that she would favor a “bill that protects the people it’s supposed to protect, but doesn’t accidentally entrap those who you don’t want to.” Cass, however, is being far too charitable. I suspect she knows that the LGBT groups who are backing the bill do, in fact, want to “entrap” those who oppose their agenda – especially parents, pastors, and “heterodox” medical professionals. The bill was worded this way on purpose, and the prosecution of dissidents and a chilling effect on the medical profession are its primary goals.

This bill would allow LGBT activists to regain ground they lost after the Cass Review was published two years ago. “The draft Bill would smuggle long-term goals of trans activists on to the statute books by the back door, despite these having been repeatedly rejected by Government,” Falkner observed. “This would include effectively mandating the ‘affirmative approach’ to supporting children, and bringing in the concept of gender self-ID, where a person who claims to be male or female must always be treated as one.”

lifesitenews

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *