Poland’s President Nawrocki blocks government legislation to censor the Internet

Karol Nawrocki. Wikimedia Commons, Marsilar, CC-BY-SA-4.0

Poland’s President Karol Nawrocki has vetoed a bill proposed by the centre-left government led by Prime Minister Donald Tusk that would have allowed authorities to block content online. Drafted by the Ministry of Digital Affairs, the bill was meant to bring the European Union’s Digital Services Act (DSA) into Polish law.

This is the second time Nawrocki has vetoed such legislation and means that Poland still has not fully implemented the DSA. The European Commission took Poland to the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) in 2025 over its failure to designate and empower a national digital services coordinator under the act.

Nawrocki rejected an earlier implementation bill on January 9, which had been backed by arguments from groups such as the conservative legal think tank Ordo Iuris Institute over fears of overregulation and administrative censorship.

Following that veto, the government split the implementation into two bills. The first, setting up the basic supervisory framework and naming the head of the telecoms regulator, the Office of Electronic Communications (UKE), as Poland’s digital services coordinator, was signed by the President in September and came into force on November 6.

The second contained the content-blocking rules and triggered the President’s veto announced on November 13.

PM Tusk defended the bill in a post on X. “Protecting children from online criminals. It is hard to imagine a more important issue that should unite people across political divides. And yet he vetoed it,” Tusk said.

Deputy digital affairs minister Dariusz Standerski said that the President was “not defending free speech” but instead “once again siding with global digital platforms and allowing them to decide what users see”.

Nawrocki’s veto was, though, welcomed by Przemysław Czarnek, the Conservative (PiS) candidate for prime minister in the 2027 parliamentary elections. Czarnek told Catholic broadcaster TV Trwam that the proposed measures had been intended to “fight the opposition” rather than actual hate speech.

Nawrocki, an ally of the opposition, has clashed repeatedly with the Tusk government and has vetoed 48 of the government’s bills since taking office in August 2025 — more than any previous Polish president.

The bill, which the Sejm, the lower house of parliament, passed on October 22, would have let regulators order the blocking of online content including criminal threats and incitement to violence, with appeals routed through courts.

Among the new powers included in the legislation, though, was authorisation for state officials to order the blocking of online content containing hate speech regarding race, nationality, ethnicity, religion or political affiliation.

Nawrocki rejected both bills on the grounds that they gave too much power to state officials and pointed to the fact that the Polish constitution has a provision in it, Article 54, which outlaws any form of preventative censorship.

During communist rule between 1944 and 1989, when Poland was governed by governments backed by the Soviet Union, the media and all publications were subject to control by state censors. Once Poland regained its independence, those responsible for formulating the 1997 constitution took care to outlaw preventative censorship.

According to the Tusk government, the legislation would have given authorities a faster way to restrict illegal material online while protecting users’ rights. Nawrocki and the right-wing opposition he is allied with rejected it, though, because preventing “hate speech” was one of the conditions for intervention by state officials.

The President and his political allies fear that “hate speech” could be used as a catch-all clause to prevent criticism of the government and content critical of “gender ideology”, climate change initiatives and the European Union.

Nawrocki said the bill, which had been narrowed and resubmitted after he vetoed an earlier version in January, gave state officials excessive power over online speech.

In a video statement, Nawrocki said the “spectre of the censor” had returned. “It is not the role of an official to rule on whether a given piece of content was a crime. That is solely the competence of the justice system and independent judges.”

He also accused the government of exploiting a series of deadly knife attacks in Polish schools in October to hurriedly push the bill through parliament. In one, at a primary school in Leszczydół-Nowiny, northeast of Warsaw, a 15-year-old killed a school caretaker.

Ministers had argued that the lack of national rules on blocking content made it harder for the authorities to act, but the President said such materials had been found and restricted under existing law in the following days.

“The state already has a wide range of tools to protect citizens from criminals. It just needs the will, the strength and the ability to use them effectively,” said Nawrocki.

“Emotional blackmail was used to push through rules that give the government what is essentially arbitrary control over what we can say, write or publish,” he stressed.

The President added that if the rules needed strengthening, the government should put forward appropriate proposals. In his view, the proposals would do nothing to improve safety and were instead “an attempt to abuse power to protect the government’s own political interests”.

Nawrocki described the bill as “controversial” and said that in normal circumstances it could be reviewed by the Constitutional Tribunal. He argued, though, that the membership of the court was disputed and that the premises of the court had been taken over by the police in order to install the judges elected by the Sejm whose credentials have not been accepted by the head of state.

Police secured the tribunal’s building in Warsaw on October 30, amid a dispute over six judges elected by the Sejm in March, four of whom Nawrocki has refused to swear in.

“But today there is no constitutional court,” he argued, adding that a veto was therefore the only option.

He said he refused to be subject to “blackmail” by the government, “especially if security and freedom are to be taken as hostages.”

The digital rights group Panoptykon Foundation had called for Poland to implement the DSA and argued that without new rules no Polish authority could effectively challenge a platform’s wrongful decision to remove lawful content, or its refusal to take down illegal posts, leaving court action as the only route, which was long, expensive and often ineffective.

Panoptykon had proposed a compromise solution by which the UKE handled clear-cut cases such as online scams, while disputes over free speech went to the courts, with a faster procedure.

Before the decision, digital affairs minister Krzysztof Gawkowski, who is also deputy prime minister, had doubled down on the government’s legislation and urged the President to sign the bill, appealing to him “as a father.”

“When we talk about children’s safety online, behind the names of laws, regulations and political disputes lies an experience that every parent can imagine,” he wrote on social media.

He said the state could not allow its response to be one of helplessness. After the veto, he said it would leave Poland without the tools the government says are needed to respond quickly to such cases.

“This veto is not just throwing legislation in the trash — it’s permission for hate, hatred and the death that the internet also brings,” Gawkowski said in a post on X.

Overriding a presidential veto requires a three-fifths majority in the Sejm, which the ruling coalition currently lacks, so Gawkowski made clear that he would be drafting another bill in the near future.

The dispute mirrors broader international debates over the DSA, with the political Right in Europe and the United States regarding the EU’s stance as a threat to free speech, while the Polish coalition government and the EU establishment view it as a vital safety and child-protection framework.

US Vice President JD Vance has repeatedly condemned what he has called Europe’s retreat from free speech, while the Trump administration has challenged the DSA as a tool of censorship. In January, US Ambassador to Poland Tom Rose praised Nawrocki’s first veto, calling the EU law “punitive and anti-American”.

Meanwhile, Nawrocki is likely to veto another government proposal when it reaches his desk: the restrictive measures bill, which the Sejm passed by 240 votes to 202 on November 6 and which must still go through the Senate.

That legislation would allow the interior minister, on the grounds of national security, to place any individual or company on a sanctions list and immediately freeze their assets without a court order. An appeal to the courts could be launched but would not automatically suspend the minister’s decision.

The bill aims to tackle foreign interference in Poland but the opposition fears it will be used to pursue the government’s opponents. This is because the proposed legislation allows the government to freeze assets for “supporting foreign interference and manipulation in the information environment”, a term critics say the legislation fails to define.

MPs from Poland’s nationalist libertarian opposition Confederation party have said that since the government claims Russian influence is behind all anti-EU and anti-government moves, ministers could seize assets in retaliation for opposition activities.

Internet freedom and the wider issue of freedom of speech are likely to be an important issue in the parliamentary elections due in autumn 2027. The opposition parties of the Right are all backing President Nawrocki’s stance that freedom of speech may only be constrained via judicial decisions and not by the executive.

brusselssignal

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *