Faced with a case of legal correction on the attribution of a third gender, Italy’s Constitutional Court denied the possibility of recognizing in the courts the alleged “non-binary” sexual identity, that is, neither masculine nor feminine. The Constitutional Court alerted that Italian law “establishes the principle of correspondence between name and sex and that, therefore, only a legislative intervention could overcome or change this rule. Its clarification is based on the fact that the binary nature of human sexuality of man and woman characterizes the varied and most disparate realms of social life, governed by the legal system, such as family law, labour law, sport, and the civil state and that, therefore, the legal recognition of an alleged third non-binary gender would disrupt the entire Italian legal and social system in such a way as to be incompatible with the faculties and attributions of the Constitutional Court or of any judge.”
Antonio Brandi, President of Pro-Life and Family Onlus, highlighted to the EFE Agency that “the Court confirms our repeated alarms about the legitimacy of the ‘alias race’ adopted increasingly by schools, given that, by permitting a student to choose a different name from the name in the register, to attribute to him the sex opposite to his own, and even without the need of a clinical diagnosis of gender dysphoria, acts out precisely the disassociation between name and sex that the Constitutional Court denies can be permitted without legislative intervention. It is more urgent than ever that the Minister of Education, Giuseppe Valditara, intervene to block the spread of this dangerous phenomenon, which reinforces in thousands of minors the absurd belief of being “born in a mistaken body,” orientating them to ways of social transition and, then, of sexual transition, which are harmful and damaging to their psychophysical health.” The same Agency verified with Italy’s Embassy in Spain that the intervention of Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni is false, to have her Government eliminate the non-binary gender in official identity documents, as asserted on the social networks, given that Italy does not include a third gender in documents and cannot do away with something that is not contemplated.